Community Rosters Question

[brettmickey]

I'm not questioning their credibility but with community rosters isn't there a chance that some players become overrated because a fan let's personal feelings get in the way of realistic numbers? I was just wondering if anyone has had problems with their rosters in the past because of unrealistic ratings? Thanks for all responses

[brettmickey]

Re: Community Rosters Question

Anybody have any past experiences with their rosters and can tell me how good/fair they are?

[UDub]

Re: Community Rosters Question

Used them several years in a row, good quality. The first batch don't have re-rated players in them.

[UltimateCaneFan]

Re: Community Rosters Question

They are the best rosters out by far. No bias on teams. Every team is fairly rated. Fans of teams give their opinions and you would be surprised to find that we are more interested in getting them right than we are overrating players. In fact as a Miami fan I have dropped a few players down to what I feel their ratings should be. Only raised 1 player up too.

[boodahisthe1]

Re: Community Rosters Question

carson's rosters are great..been using them for a while and i love em

[brobamigo]

Re: Community Rosters Question

i dont think the first batch of rosters will have edited ratings..which is what i want..dont really get that indepth as to editing players ratings

[brettmickey]

Re: Community Rosters Question

Thanks for all of the feedback! It's great knowing there is an option out there that tweaks ratings and appearance without becoming biased. I will definitely have to go download them once they are finalized

[blkrptnt819]

So they do name, equipment and remove and add players on the first batch? I'm totally new to the process of NCAA. This is my first year following.

[Leon Sandcastle]

Re: Community Rosters Question

The community rosters are the best out there for they take there time which each team which makes it great! Also im pretty sure they do edit ratings for EA doesn't make the ratings the best for example take martinez from Nebraska they have him as a slow qb when he had blazing speed last year. The community rosters are definitely the best to start an online dynasty and a offline dynasty

[brobamigo]

Re: Community Rosters Question

So they do name, equipment and remove and add players on the first batch? I'm totally new to the process of NCAA. This is my first year following.

i took this from the official thread

"In this year's addition of 2012 you will the addition of Head Coaches. Each team will be named with the Head Coaches as well. We will be doing the following ...

1) Complete naming of all 120 Teams
2) Correct heights, weights and skin color.
3) Head Coaches named
4) Dreads taken on and off of all players accordingly
5) Equipment changes.
6) Coordinators named
"

[Jasong7777]

Re: Community Rosters Question

These rosters are great every year. Thats why I love the fact that they are taking their time these.

[blkrptnt819]

i took this from the official thread

"In this year's addition of 2012 you will the addition of Head Coaches. Each team will be named with the Head Coaches as well. We will be doing the following ...

1) Complete naming of all 120 Teams
2) Correct heights, weights and skin color.
3) Head Coaches named
4) Dreads taken on and off of all players accordingly
5) Equipment changes.
6) Coordinators named
"

Thank you, I really appreciate this.

[RyRog345]

Re: Community Rosters Question

Yeah, I've always thought of this as well. Do teams overall ratings ever drop after re-rating players? And I'm not talking about Bama going from like a 99 overall to a 96 overall.