Promise: solid playing time 1st year

[awkwardmoment]

so that promise of solid playing time first year on campus, does it apply to redshirt or not?


so if I redshirt the kid, will I break my promise?

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

yes it will break the promise if u redshirt him during his first year on campus.

[speedy43]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Well, if you redshirt him how is he supposed to get solid playing time?

[Sportsbuck]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Just to add on, he has to be in the first position on the depth chart to get fulfill this promise.

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Just to add on, he has to be in the first position on the depth chart to get fulfill this promise.

really? what if he is the number 2 rb on the depth chart but splits carries 50/50?

[Roggie]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

really? what if he is the number 2 rb on the depth chart but splits carries 50/50?

Doesn't matter. Has to be starter.

Actually, #1 on Depth Chart, even if 2 guys start.

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Doesn't matter. Has to be starter.

Actually, #1 on Depth Chart, even if 2 guys start.

thats so dumb. why not make the promise "be a starter first year on campus". solid playing time doesnt imply starter in any way.

[jkra0512]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

really? what if he is the number 2 rb on the depth chart but splits carries 50/50?

If he's getting half the carries why not just have him #1? Not getting your logic here...

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

If he's getting half the carries why not just have him #1? Not getting your logic here...

because if 2 rbs split the carries 50/50 then somebody has to be 1 and somebody has to be 2.

and ur missing the boat anyway. the promise is solid playing time first year on campus, not be first on depth chart first year on campus.

[jkra0512]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Well if solid playing time equals needs to be #1 on the depth chart to acheive that goal and you have two RBs who share 50% of the carries, one of which is the player you made the promise to and you put him at #2, well looks to me like you're breaking your promise.

[redsfan4life]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

What if you say No Redshirt first year on Campus?

If you get him in on special teams will he be satisfied?

[37]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

What if you say No Redshirt first year on Campus?

If you get him in on special teams will he be satisfied?

I would assume, yes

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

Well if solid playing time equals needs to be #1 on the depth chart to acheive that goal and you have two RBs who share 50% of the carries, one of which is the player you made the promise to and you put him at #2, well looks to me like you're breaking your promise.

solid playing time doesnt equal being number one on the depth chart. only in EA's fantasy world does it equal that.

if u have to start the player for the promise to be fulfilled, then the promise should be called "put player at #1 on depth chart".

solid playing time doesnt equal being a starter. two completly different things.

[tetoleetd]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

What if you say No Redshirt first year on Campus?

If you get him in on special teams will he be satisfied?

u dont have to play him at all. as long as u didnt redshirt him u will be good.

[jkra0512]

Re: Promise: solid playing time 1st year

lol, I agree with you 100%, but to fulfill your promise you're going to have to do it.