These settings have been giving me some really good games and stats where realistic.

Updated 9/4/11
Game Options
Play call style: conventional
Quarter Length: 8 min (8-10) optional
Coaching Tips: off
Play Clock: on
Strategy Pad Quick Links: on
Coordinator Audio: off
Coordinator Subtitles: off
Accelerated Clock: off
Camera Settings: standard
Auto Strafe: off ( optional )
Auto Sprint: off ( optional )
Injuries: 20
Fatigue: 55 ( still testing )
Game Speed: very fast
Player Min Speed Threshold: 35
Motion Sensor Function: 60
Player Skill
Passing
QB Accuracy: 50
Pass Blocking: 25
WR Catching: 25
Rushing
Broken Tackles: 25
Run Blocking: 35
Fumbles: 50
Pass Defense
Reaction Time: 25
Interceptions: 25
Pass Rushing: 20
Rush Defense
Reaction Time: 50
Block Shedding: 10
Tackling: 35
CPU Skill
Passing
QB Accuracy: 50
Pass Blocking: 10
WR Catching: 19
Rushing
Broken Tackles: 20
Run Blocking: 15
Fumbles: 50
Pass Defense
Reaction Time: 5
Interceptions: 15
Pass Rushing: 15
Rush Defense
Reaction Time: 10
Block Shedding: 5
Tackling: 20
Special Teams
FG Power: 35
FG Accuracy: 35
Punt Power: 50
Punt Accuracy: 40
Kickoff Power: 40
Penalties
Offside: 60
False Start: 55
Holding: 49
Facemask: 55
Clipping: 50
Roughing The Passer: 50
All other penalties are set at 100
Visual Feedback
Pre-Snap menu: off (optional)
In Game Hints: off
Player Names: off (optional) even though without them feels like real football
Strategy Pad Display: off (optional)
Volume Control
Master Volume: 100
In Game Commentary: 70
Stadium Speakers: 100
Crowd Volume: 100
On Field: 25 or 0 (off)
Menu Music: 70 (optional)
Menu SFX: 0
Hopefully people enjoy my settings. I'm still testing them but some feedback and opinions are welcome. Stats and scores are cool too.

Comment