Recommended Videos

37 · 09-05-2011, 11:59 PM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by Trinity120

I'm doing a 32 team chise and I want to trade him from the Bengals. The team I'm looking at is the 49ers or Seahawks. Why? Because one, they need a solid #1 QB. Two, Carson is from Cali so it would be a good fit for him imo irl. And if it's Seattle, he'd be back with his old coach from USC. My question is, what's a fair trade? I'm thinking a 2nd and a 4th round pick? I think a first round pick is too much imo...

Options are:

2012 2nd & 4th rd picks

2012 2nd rd pick & 2013 2nd rd pick

2012 3rd, 4th, & 5th rd picks

2012 3rd & 4th rd picks only

What seems most fair? I'm not gonna wait for rosters to come out, and wanna have fun and keep him in the game but realistically want to by trading him to a team in need. Both of those teams are NFC West teams as well so he'd be out of the AFC. Either one of those teams would be a perfect fit for him imo(esp SF).

i'd prolly go with option #2......that'd be the fairest trade outta the 4 imo...i rather give up a pick in 2 separate years then give up multiple picks in the same year...especially for a guy like carson whose still a pretty damn good qb..if i had to pick seattle or 'frisco, i'd prolly ship him off to seattle cause i think they'll have a worser season then frisco so the draft picks would be better for u

**knucklar** · 09-05-2011, 11:59 PM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Why don't you try asking for a 2nd round pick and a Seahawks receiver? The Bengals are short on WOs this year. Maybe try Mike Williams?

**DarthRambo** · 09-06-2011, 12:32 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by knucklar

Why don't you try asking for a 2nd round pick and a Seahawks receiver? The Bengals are short on WOs this year. Maybe try Mike Williams?

Hmm...I dunno about for Mike Williams, seems like a little much. What about Golden Tate?

In 32 team chise i dont get trade offer rejections so I gotta make it fair as possible lol...

Option 2 so far is what I'm goin with to Seattle....

**Pringles** · 09-06-2011, 12:38 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

try trading him for a new owner that would be fair.

37 · 09-06-2011, 12:44 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by Trinity120

Hmm...I dunno about for Mike Williams, seems like a little much. What about Golden Tate?

In 32 team chise i dont get trade offer rejections so I gotta make it fair as possible lol...

Option 2 so far is what I'm goin with to Seattle....

2nd rounder AND mike williams is a lil over the top for me....i still rather have the 2013 2nd rounder rather then golden tate if ur gunna make me choose between the two

**DarthRambo** · 09-06-2011, 12:47 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by NoFatGirlz4Me37

2nd rounder AND mike williams is a lil over the top for me....i still rather have the 2013 2nd rounder rather then golden tate if ur gunna make me choose between the two

I agree...ok Carson Palmer to Seahawks for 2012 2nd rd pick & 2013 2nd rd pick. That's fair

37 · 09-06-2011, 12:50 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by Trinity120

I agree...ok Carson Palmer to Seahawks for 2012 2nd rd pick & 2013 2nd rd pick. That's fair

I would tend to agree with that

**ChildishAssassin** · 09-06-2011, 12:59 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

2 2ed round picks is a bit much Was gave up a 2ed pick and a 4th in the next draft for McNabb I would say the same 2012 2ed and a 2013 4th

**DarthRambo** · 09-06-2011, 01:01 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by ChildishAssassin

2 2ed round pics a bit much Was gave up a 2ed pick and a 4th in the next draft for McNabb I would say the same 2012 2ed and a 2013 4th

McNabb is older tho...been in the league 4 years longer than Palmer therefore Palmer has a little bit more value than McNabb did

37 · 09-06-2011, 01:11 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by ChildishAssassin

2 2ed round picks is a bit much Was gave up a 2ed pick and a 4th in the next draft for McNabb I would say the same 2012 2ed and a 2013 4th

I don't think 2 2nd-rounders is a bit much....as the OP alluded to, u can't compare mcnabb to palmer....palmer has always had more pure talent then mcnabb and if seattle can somehow stabilize their O-line, their offense isn't that bad...carson still has enough years in him to be a top qb...not to say ur suggestion was completely unreasonable but it wasn't one of the OP's options..

**SoulAssassin** · 09-06-2011, 01:32 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by Trinity120

I'm doing a 32 team chise and I want to trade him from the Bengals. The team I'm looking at is the 49ers or Seahawks. Why? Because one, they need a solid #1 QB. Two, Carson is from Cali so it would be a good fit for him imo irl. And if it's Seattle, he'd be back with his old coach from USC. My question is, what's a fair trade? I'm thinking a 2nd and a 4th round pick? I think a first round pick is too much imo...

Options are:

2012 2nd & 4th rd picks

2012 2nd rd pick & 2013 2nd rd pick

2012 3rd, 4th, & 5th rd picks

2012 3rd & 4th rd picks only

What seems most fair? I'm not gonna wait for rosters to come out, and wanna have fun and keep him in the game but realistically want to by trading him to a team in need. Both of those teams are NFC West teams as well so he'd be out of the AFC. Either one of those teams would be a perfect fit for him imo(esp SF).

I sent Carson to SF also. But for a 2nd and 3rd (2012).

I agree a 1st rd pick is too much.... and probably a 2nd and 4th is actually more realistic, however.

37 · 09-06-2011, 01:34 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by SoulAssassin

I sent Carson to SF also. But for a 2nd and 3rd (2012).

I agree a 1st rd pick is too much.... and probably a 2nd and 4th is actually more realistic, however.

if it was next year's 4th, and was one of the options, i'd probably give more thought to that....like i said before, there's just something about giving up multiple picks in the same draft that irks me lol....especially if they're 4th-round or better

**DarthRambo** · 09-06-2011, 01:36 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by SoulAssassin

I sent Carson to SF also. But for a 2nd and 3rd (2012).

I agree a 1st rd pick is too much.... and probably a 2nd and 4th is actually more realistic, however.

Yeah I'm on the fence about it lol

I've decided to flip a coin for SF or Seattle....and the winner IS! Seattle haha! That was fun

choices are between 2 nd rd picks from 2012 and 2013, or a 2nd and 4th from 2012 only. Leaning towards the 2nd and 4th now I think about it more

37 · 09-06-2011, 01:37 AM

Re: Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Originally posted by Trinity120

Yeah I'm on the fence about it lol

I've decided to flip a coin for SF or Seattle....and the winner IS! Seattle haha! That was fun

choices are between 2 nd rd picks from 2012 and 2013, or a 2nd and 4th from 2012 only. Leaning towards the 2nd and 4th now I think about it more

cant really argue with u with either choice u make as both seem realistic and fair

Recommended Videos

Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Trading Carson Palmer fairly

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment