Who deserves this Heisman?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • notrekane
    Rookie
    • Jul 2012
    • 15

    #1

    Who deserves this Heisman?

    My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats:

    Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak)

    De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0
    Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0
    Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose
    Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5
    times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year
    – 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's.

    Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble
    327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches
    the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over
    once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's.

    Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s
    349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches
    the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every
    55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's.

    Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6
    Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4
    times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and
    a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD.

    Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!
  • mfbball04
    Rookie
    • Jan 2009
    • 367

    #2
    Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

    Originally posted by notrekane
    My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats:

    Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak)

    De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0
    Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0
    Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose
    Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5
    times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year
    – 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's.

    Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble
    327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches
    the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over
    once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's.

    Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s
    349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches
    the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every
    55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's.

    Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6
    Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4
    times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and
    a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD.

    Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!
    im not going to vote for Barkley because those stats are unrealistic.. so i'll go with Woods

    Comment

    • D0GGERT D0G
      Rookie
      • Jul 2011
      • 311

      #3
      Malcom Brown

      Comment

      • mattrd39
        Pro
        • Sep 2010
        • 578

        #4
        Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

        Even though I'm not an Oregon fan...
        1-Thomas
        2-Miller
        3-Barkley
        4-Brown
        5-Woods

        In real life, it would probably go to Miller though, playing QB at the bigger school that is also undefeated.

        Comment

        • utahman27
          Rookie
          • Jul 2010
          • 46

          #5
          Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

          1. Brown

          2. Barkley

          3. Thomas

          4. Woods

          5. Miller

          Comment

          • Wavebird99
            MVP
            • May 2009
            • 1203

            #6
            Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

            Originally posted by utahman27
            1. Brown

            2. Barkley

            3. Thomas

            4. Woods

            5. Miller
            This, except switch Miller and Woods around.

            Comment

            • dingleberryfinn
              Banned
              • May 2010
              • 1736

              #7
              Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

              Miller then Barkley, his int's are too high for my taste.
              Last edited by dingleberryfinn; 07-18-2012, 04:34 PM.

              Comment

              • TryHard_Nation
                Rookie
                • Dec 2011
                • 454

                #8
                Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                Originally posted by notrekane
                My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats:

                Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak)

                De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0
                Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0
                Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose
                Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5
                times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year
                – 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's.

                Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble
                327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches
                the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over
                once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's.

                Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s
                349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches
                the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every
                55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's.

                Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6
                Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4
                times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and
                a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD.

                Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!
                1.Brown
                2. Woods
                3. Thomas
                4. Miller
                5. Barkerly
                "YOU MAY ALL GO TO HELL AND I WILL GO TO TEXAS"
                --DAVY CROCKETT

                Comment

                • Floridastatefan02
                  Rookie
                  • May 2012
                  • 123

                  #9
                  Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                  Seems like RB's are the only ones that win it.

                  Georgia Freshman RB who ended up getting suspended in real life won it in my first year, even though Iowa's QB deserved it the most.

                  I'd use names but I am not very up-to-date with College football!

                  Comment

                  • nskojo
                    Rookie
                    • Jul 2012
                    • 20

                    #10
                    Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                    Malcolm Brown. Undefeated with those stats no brainer

                    Comment

                    • buckeyekid1996
                      Rookie
                      • Dec 2011
                      • 6

                      #11
                      Braxton Miller

                      Comment

                      • NEOPARADIGM
                        Banned
                        • Jul 2009
                        • 2788

                        #12
                        Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                        Originally posted by mfbball04
                        im not going to vote for Barkley because those stats are unrealistic.
                        66 TDs is mildly crazy, but nothing else is even a record.

                        Comment

                        • jayenomics
                          Banned
                          • Aug 2009
                          • 2076

                          #13
                          Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                          1.Brown
                          2. Thomas
                          3. Woods
                          4. Miller
                          5. Barkerly

                          Comment

                          • zukes
                            Pro
                            • Mar 2005
                            • 703

                            #14
                            Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                            I think you should have left the names off.

                            Comment

                            • Colt45
                              Rookie
                              • May 2011
                              • 656

                              #15
                              Re: Who deserves this Heisman?

                              Originally posted by mfbball04
                              im not going to vote for Barkley because those stats are unrealistic.. so i'll go with Woods
                              Well this is just what the computer does!

                              Comment

                              Working...