majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

[majesty95]

Please post any corrections that need to be made (or issues you find) in this thread. Please keep in mind that I did not (and did not intend to) edit player height/weight/appearances or update depth charts. Please refrain from posting those issues in here as those are not part of this update.

Also, please keep in mind that the rating edits I did were my evaluations of those players based on countless hours of video watched and scouting reports and analysis that I read. Please do not use this thread to discuss/debate why/how our opinions differ. They are just that, opinions. If you feel they should be different, by all means please make your own roster set with those differences.

With that being said, if I have left out a player that is listed among the top 20 at his position, in his class, then please post that in here. However, you need to provide proof as to why you feel they were left out (publication, online ranking, etc.)

Please keep in mind that I spent well over 50 hours working on this update and I did it all for FREE. Please be kind and keep your suggestions/corrections to the topic.

[Scott]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Texas
RT Paden Kelly is not on the team anymore, replace with Freshman S Adrian Colbert.
FB Chet Moss can be replaced with FB Alex De La Torre.
CB Kendall Sanders will be playing WR.
SS Bryant Jackson will be playing WR.
K William Russ can be replaced with Freshman Nick Jordan
P Ben Pruitt can be replaced with Duke Transfer P Alex King.
DT Chris Whaley can be replaced with Freshman RB Daje Johnson.
Another key missing player is Freshman Timothy Cole.

[majesty95]

Texas doesn't have an official depth chart out so it is hard to update them. Mostly I just did ratings edits.

EDIT: I did all of the edits you suggested (and uploaded) accept for P and K. I did not find any info on those two players earning the starting nod yet, so I'm going to leave them at default until something official is released.

Appreciate the help!

[ebarws6]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Stanford

HB Tyler Gaffney signed with the Pittsburgh Pirates and has left the team.

Two ratings adjustments, one which I'm sure you'll want to make:

1. Shayne Skov, MLB

Deserving of much more than a rating of 79 to say the least. Most people who have watched him play just call him an animal, he swarms to the ball and has great instincts. He lead the team in tackles in 2010, and was leading the team in 2011 before he was lost for the season because of an injury.

Phil Steele tabbed him as a pres-season AA: http://www.philsteele.com/Pdf/2012Pr...l-American.pdf

#2 ILB in class of 2013 according to this site:

http://www.nfldraftscout.com/ratings/profilexnews.php?pyid=89784&draftyear=2013&genpos=ILB

And for what it's worth he's on whatever watch list there is for linebackers, though those lists don't really mean much.

2. CB Wayne Lyons (FS in the game)

This one is more your call. Lyons almost took over one of the starting corner spots in the first few games last year before, like Skov, succumbing to a season-ending injury. Stanford was very lucky to get him, as he had 49 scholarship offers. So far it looks like he has locked up one of the starting corner spots, so even just a rating change to reflect that would be fine.

Named to "All-breakthrough team": http://www.cbssports.com/collegefoot...tball/19609150


I will admit, it is kinda hard to promote your own players trying not to sound like a homer while also providing some sort of tangible evidence.

[majesty95]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Stanford was another without a depth chart out which made it difficult. Guys like Skov are easy to miss (although I use Draft Scout so should have picked him up). Lyons was another that's easy to overlook without a depth chart.

Updated and uploaded. Thanks!

[HogsandRams]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

why didnt chris gragg or cobi hamilton on the razorbacks get an update? They are easily top 20 players

[majesty95]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

why didnt chris gragg or cobi hamilton on the razorbacks get an update? They are easily top 20 players

I had them rated at 91 OVR (Hamilton) and 86 OVR (Gragg) prior to editing. That is what they are in my roster. If that is what they are in the default roster then I did not change them because that's where they were already rated.

Also, most players already rated in the defaults within ~2 points of what I projected them at I did not re-rate. I was mostly concerned with improving (or decreasing) players who were obviously in need of an update.

[luvmyraiderz]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

fair enough, fair enough :]
Glad to hear Kline got a boost tho. Although I don't agree with Allen not being a to ptier receiver :] Bet these will be good tho. Can't wait to be finished, hopefully it will be tonight!Brandon Bigelow maybe as well? :] WR Maurice Harris hopefully got a boost sine every reciever beised Allen is in the low 70's :[
and thanks for adding cal to the full team list. appreciate it.

[HogsandRams]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

fair enough, fair enough :]
Glad to hear Kline got a boost tho. Although I don't agree with Allen not being a to ptier receiver :] Bet these will be good tho. Can't wait to be finished, hopefully it will be tonight!Brandon Bigelow maybe as well? :] WR Maurice Harris hopefully got a boost sine every reciever beised Allen is in the low 70's :[
and thanks for adding cal to the full team list. appreciate it.

the roster is done and uploaded...

[woodsmall12]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Most look pretty spot on IMO ... had a few suggestions and may offer up a few more when I have more free time

Isiah Lewis SS at Mich St at 83 ovr
Steele ranked at #17 best and projected 1st team All B1G
1st 22 SS's you have at 86+
Rated #4 of 91 on NFL Draft Scout in 2014

Dexter McCoil SS at Tulsa at 86 ovr
Steele at #3 best
#12 out of 97 FS prospects on NFL Draft Scout
Named to Bronco Nagurski watch list (best defensive player) (out of 84 on list)
Conflicting reports on whether he is SS or FS

Tony Jefferson FS at Oklahoma at 87 ovr
Steele at #5 and projected 4th team All American and 1st team All Big 12 with Vaccaro
#2 out of 89 on NFL Draft Scout

Tanner Miller FS at Iowa at 85 ovr
Steele #13 and projected #6 in class of 2014 on NFL Draft Scout
26 players currently ahead of him at 86+

Ben Bartholomew FB at Tenn at 86 ovr
Not on Steele list and #19 on NFL Draft Scout
I would drop his ratings since he is slotted as the 4th best FB

John Simon LE at Ohio St at 90 ovr
His strength needs to improve ... currently at 79 ... I have seen other ppl mention this
He is projected 2nd team AA and others fall around 86 strength

Devonte Holloman listed as SS at South Carolina 89 ovr
#13 OLB under Steele and just named to the Butkus watch list for Linebackers however in the game is listed as SS and currently #2 SS on NFL Draft Scout ... probably need clarification as to whether he should now be a Linebacker or not ... any **** fans out there? This would then cause a shift with some other position players

[woodsmall12]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

A recent transfer ...

Backup RG John Deyo at MSU transferring to Western Michigan

http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20120718/SPORTS0202/207180404/1132/sports0202/Offensive-lineman-John-Deyo-will-transfer-from-MSU-Western-Michigan

[woodsmall12]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Michael Dyer of Auburn fame is now moving on from Ark State to Pitt St

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1264504-former-auburn-running-back-michael-dyer-transferring-2013-draft-stock-rising

[woodsmall12]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

Need to remove this Wiscy DT ... Kohout is done ...

http://espn.go.com/college-football/story/_/id/8183772/migraines-end-career-wisconsin-badgers-defensive-tackle-jordan-kohout

[majesty95]

Ok. I'll get to work in them this weekend. Still need to update UNC too

[Davis30788]

Re: majesty95's Roster CORRECTION/ISSUES Thread

BGSU

QB
-Trent Hurley has transfered to SO ME St. You can replace him with Malik Stoke, younger brother of Je'Ron Stokes.

RB
-Erique Geiger isn't on the team. He should be replaced with John Pettigrew
-Andre Givens transfered from PITT to BGSU.
-Coy Brown will be playing LB

WR
-Add Je'Ron Strokes. Went to Michigan last year.
-Bart Tanski was Mr. Ohio as a Senior as a QB, and lead his team to two state title births. Could you bump up his QB ratings a tad so he's not at the 40 default

LT
Kyle Bryant was dismissed from the team in the Spring. Replace with Fahn Cooper, who will be starting at LT in his place

LG Chip Robinson has moved to starting Center
C Dominic Flewellyn has moved to starting LG
Starting RT Jordan Roussos has moved to starting RG

LE Anthony Lawson. So i looked him up, and idk who he is. Last record of him being on the team according to the official football website was 2010. I would turn him into DE Shaq Hall, or maybe one of the Freshman left out of the game. Or perhaps, C Chief kekuewa, a Juco transfer who is pushing C Chip Robinson for playing time.

LOLB Eric Jordan. Same as Lawson, not on the roster. Replace with OLB/DB Brian Sutton.

Jordan Leininger. Not on the team. replace with Josh Pettus, a JUCO transfer who plays CB

Aunre Davis and JD Davis graduated. replace with Johnny Joseph and freshman James Sanford

Jerry Gates goes by BooBoo

Move Aaron Foster to FS