NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

[mtownballa12]

I'm looking for a college football game to put a lot of time into in order to hold me over this off-season. I was wondering which game do you prefer? What are the bugs/glitches/etc in each and which do you think produces the biggest "fun-factor"?

[Clipperazi]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

I'm looking for a college football game to put a lot of time into in order to hold me over this off-season. I was wondering which game do you prefer? What are the bugs/glitches/etc in each and which do you think produces the biggest "fun-factor"?

11 or 12 for sure cuz 13 got the DB glitch....in 11 the gameplay is pretty solid but the tackling looks fake as hell. in 12 the tackling is good but if u run a QB option, its failed from the start, with the corners from whichever side ur running the ball to full-on engaging with u and the running back, as if they knew the play from when u selected it. sliders cant fix that either

[malky]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

Never played 11. But between 12 and 13 12 for sure--- less freezing. 13 with all the freezing is unacceptable

[Buckeye Country]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

They all have issues, but 13 was unplayable, traded it in. 12 was too frustrating with the deep ball too open and the crazy comebacks. Went to 11, has issues, but playing it now.

[Clipperazi]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

yeah I'd have to agree that 11 is better than all of them. Thinking about getting a new ps3 since my old 1 died just to play 11 again...

[NickS97]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

I would say get 11 because its was one of my favriote ncaa games but the recurting in the dynasty was really hard for me. i dont know if anyone had that problem or i just sucked

[WipeOut464]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

11 by far. It has the most fun-factor and the subsequent games don't offer any groundbreaking features. 12 is a glitchy, frustrating nightmare. 13 has freezing and deep-ball pass coverage issues.

Plus you can find 11 for next to nothing.

[mtownballa12]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

Looks like 11 wins in a landslide. Thanks for the input everyone. I'm gonna look to pick it up in a day or two

[jello1717]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

Looks like 11 wins in a landslide. Thanks for the input everyone. I'm gonna look to pick it up in a day or two

'13 won here:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...orite-gen.html

[mtownballa12]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

'13 won here:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...orite-gen.html

Wow. I'm surprised with that. It seems like every post I read, close to everybody has a bone to pick with 13. yet it still wins in a straight up vote. That's fascinating.

[I3RIS3H]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

I'll have to go with 11. This series has gone straight down hill since then. 11 has issues, but 12 was unplayable for me... didn't even buy 13.

[xcrushx]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

Personally, I think 13 is the best of all 3 of them. 12 was horrible, in my opinion. The gameplay just didn't do it for me. The psychic defense was ridiculous and made the game unplayable.

11 was good but the lack of coaching carousel really brought the game down. In terms of dynasty mode, as broken as coaching carousel might seem it really does add a lot to the game. I went back and tried to play 11 not too long ago and found myself bored without coaching carousel.

13 is not without its flaws but I do think it is a solid game. I prefer coach mode. The recruiting is a lot better. The new dynamic school ratings add a lot to recruiting. And coaching carousel actually works better even though it is still seriously flawed.

[raneman85]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?

13 is a more polished version of 11. They were smoking something when they made 12.

[LucianoJJ]

Re: NCAA 11, 12, or 13?


NCAA 12 is the one to avoid. While I liked NCAA 11 better for a lot of reasons, I think the improved passing in NCAA 13 make it hard to go back to NCAA 11. And that's with the dreaded DB glitch!