Operation Sports Forums - Madden 15 Slider Log

** 11/3/2014 recommended set: The All Pro User v Cpu CFM/Play Now set (scroll down to the second slider set in that thread)

** Please refine for recommendation: JaymeeAwesome's Realistic Game Stats Sliders (M15 CFM) Style Sliders (top notch potential, please see notes for fine tuning)

Hey all, long time since I've posted here but yuh know... life and stuff.

I'll get right too it, this thread is where I will be posting logs of 3 games of each slider set on OS. The games will be the same and a new CFM will be started for each set for fairness. I know 3 isn't the largest sample size for any slider set, but it will give us a good idea of what's out there instead of trying to sift through all of the posts in each slider thread.

Please do NOT hijack this thread!!!

Don't post your own box scored please. If you have a box score you'd like to post, please send me the link and I'll have a look. If it looks legit, then I'll post it under the appropriate slider. Yes, mention the slider you used WITHOUT any changes made too it.

DO recommend slider sets to test.

Rules

The only rules I follow is that I do not switch defenders, nor do I hardly every control any defenders. I do not user catch and I have coach mode on so that I can pay attention to the receivers getting open. I also hardly ever control the running back and for picking plays I normally use one of the "strategy" options.

The Slider Log
Every setting in the sliders/settings is exactly as it is in its thread.

Armor & Sword's/Marino's All-Pro Slow Simulation Style Sliders

Box Scores and Reviews

Spoiler

Game #1

Spoiler

3 scrambles attempted
Few too many CPU runs
CPU run seemed over-powered at times
User running was underwhelming (couple mediocre plays made the avg)
defense got to me several times before ball was handed off
questionable QB comp % but not too bad
Not enough targets to primary receivers
Majority of targets to TE/RB
Sacks were excellent.
Tackles, sacks coming from the wrong positions
0 fumbles
CPU QB avg/att seemed low (5.6)
Deep balls have 100% tight coverage, even when leading. Defenders react too fast to bat ball away from 10 yards out.

Game #2

Spoiler

Really fun game near the end due to a last minute turnover that nearly cost me the game.

Clearly User running is too weak (Foster should 3.8-5.2, higher end vs Raiders)
QB comp % determined so far to be too high
CPU QB avg too low (5.3)
Good job in targeting primary receivers
Too many sacks (last game ok, so we'll see)
Felt like Madden 4th quarter cheat in affect
Penalties are extremely low
1 successful deep ball for 89 yards (Andre Johnson), tackled at 1

Game #3

Spoiler

This game was almost like a blooper real, it was a weird game filled with flop plays, misreads and tons of sacks.

Way too many sacks
Misreads by the User QB when throwing coach mode.
Every TD by CPU was an overhead deep bomb
Rarely can User QB throw and overhead bomb
Running felt over-powered, possibly to balance other games out
QB comp % good
This entire game seemed to balance stats for the other 2 games.
I felt forced to lose instead of faulty play
Too few penalties
CPU avg 12.4 per pass!

3 Game Stats

Spoiler

Final Thoughts

Spoiler

Charter04's Madden NFL 15 Sliders

The All Madden User v Cpu CFM/Play Now set

Box Scores and Reviews

Spoiler

Game #1

Spoiler

This was one of the worst games of Madden I've played in a long time from a realism standpoint. Hopefully it was just a fluke because Charter04 is known for making great slider sets.

CPU QB comp % way too high
All deep balls = INT
All INT attempts were successful, no drops
Running Game was abysmal until the 4th quarter when CPU/User RB got a couple big plays. Until then, RB avg was 1.8ypc
The passing distribution actually made sense (higher WR Catching results in more targets to RBs). Will want to use this setting, it's exciting.
User tackles/sacks came from correct positions
No User INT attempts
CPU went into cheat mode (4th quarter)
CPU robo-QB was in effect
Too few penalties
Sacks weren't rediculous. All but 1 were in 4th quarter. Me thinks All-Madden is the culprit to robo-QB, cheat-mode and sack issue.

Game #2

Spoiler

Game #3

Spoiler

This game actually felt kind of normal up until the 2nd half when things started going haywire. Rarely did anything feel natural in this game.

Too many INTs
Game feels forced or predetermined
Robo-QB kicks in randomly
4th qtr madden cheat mode (common amongst all 3 games)
Stats are too much. League can't compete
Running game was OK. Outside runs are locked off.

Final Thoughts

Spoiler

The All Pro User v Cpu CFM/Play Now set

Box Scores and Reviews

Spoiler

JaymeeAwesome's Realistic Game Stats Sliders (M15 CFM) Style Sliders

Box Scores and Reviews

Spoiler

Game #1

Spoiler

This game was OK as I didn't see a ton of issues. 2 USER scores were from turnovers near the goal line. CPU lost TOP or may have won.

Too many USER sacks
Pass distribution was excellent!
4th quarter comeback mode possible
Running Game felt weak on both sides
Didn't like that FS lead in tackles
Slow game speed feels sluggish. Change to liking, doesn't affect sliders.
Good QB YPA
Too many CPU pass deflections compared to USER (8/1)

Game #2

Spoiler

We destroyed the Raiders but it was still fun and believable as that's not too far fetched in reality. That's why I'm playing 3 games right? Each game is different.

Running seemed fine. Big AVGs were mainly from 1 big run.
Game felt fair on both sides as players played more or less true to their ratings.
QBs were scrambling and throwing balls away, even Derek Carr.
Players were swatting balls.
Deep balls are still impossible without a slant route (underthrown).
Is good that the CPU yardage totals were close to USERS
I could see the Raider having 5 turnovers
Good amount of penalties
LOVE leading tackler being LB and in double digits
Did not like JJ Watt with only 1 tackle and no sacks
Good amount of sacks
Maybe too many INTs for USER and too few for CPU
CPU pass distributions was not good

Game #3

Spoiler

Game was kind of fun but probably the most realistic set so far compared to the ones above it. The main problem with these sliders is that the CPU can't score or get the upper hand.

Good amount of turnovers
Great QB comp %
Enjoyed seeing the CPU finally beat me in passing yards
First set to have CPU go for 4th down conversions
No shortage of penalties, maybe reduce False Start a bit to get Encroachment in there
Running game was pretty good on both sides
Pass distribution stinks
Far too many sacks (could be variance)
Would like to see leading sackers come from DL, came from LB
Love seeing leading tacklers be LB
Auto subs didn't seem to work for RBs

Final Thoughts

Spoiler

theSliderWhizperer’s M15 - GAME CHANGER SLIDERS HALLOW'S EVE SLIDER BREW

Box Scores and Reviews

Coming Soon