Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mo2thewillyo
    Pro
    • May 2011
    • 635

    #1

    Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

    Now that people have had plenty of experience using Madden 15 and tweaking things with sliders... would you say is better: get Madden 15 or stick with Madden 25? What makes either game better? Thanks for detailed comparison and analysis.

    Also I am a big fan of classic rosters... do teams have plenty of retro uniforms... home AND away retro jerseys? I know past maddens only had home retro uniforms and not road jerseys.
  • oneamongthefence
    Nothing to see here folks
    • Apr 2009
    • 5683

    #2
    Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

    They have the same retro jerseys. I like Madden 15 better. Its more fluid and on all madden it plays pretty balanced. The user coverage on defense is pretty below average though but it can be minimized with slider tweaks. The CCF mode has been tweaked for the better too aside from some bad regression problems.
    Because I live in van down by the river...

    Comment

    • illiterateoption
      Banned
      • Mar 2013
      • 240

      #3
      Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

      Each game plays a decent game of Madden. I think M15 is a nice upgrade to M25 for the rosters, gauntlet, kick meter, and a few other very subtle items.

      I prefer the way M25 had the draft classes set up in CCM. Branching storylines are very limited in M15 and although the classes weren't random, I appreciated the way M25 connected you with each featured prospect.

      M25 also appears to be a bit more "stable" product.

      I think M25 and M15 are the best Maddens we've seen in the X360/PS3 era.

      Comment

      • mo2thewillyo
        Pro
        • May 2011
        • 635

        #4
        Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

        There was hype about Madden 25 having better play from the secondary. Is it legit, if so how, otherwise would you say Madden 15 and 25 there isn't much difference in secondary play

        Comment

        • willy981
          Rookie
          • Apr 2013
          • 35

          #5
          Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

          If you like route jumping,then Madden 25 is your game.I haven't played Madden 15 and won't upgrade again until they bring back NCAA.So until then im Playing Madden 25 and NCAA 14.
          PSN:willy981 (Let me know that your from OS and i'll accept)

          Fans Of:

          Tennessee
          Titans
          Philadelphia Eagles
          Tennessee Vols
          Nashville Predators
          Philadelphia 76ers
          Chelsea

          Hillwood HS(TN) #84 Class of 2016

          Comment

          • jhobbins
            Rookie
            • May 2011
            • 9

            #6
            Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

            Originally posted by mo2thewillyo
            Now that people have had plenty of experience using Madden 15 and tweaking things with sliders... would you say is better: get Madden 15 or stick with Madden 25? What makes either game better? Thanks for detailed comparison and analysis.

            Also I am a big fan of classic rosters... do teams have plenty of retro uniforms... home AND away retro jerseys? I know past maddens only had home retro uniforms and not road jerseys.
            if you're playing ps3/360 then stick with madden 25
            If you're on ps4/one then get 15, it's definetley worth it

            Comment

            • acmemb
              Just started!
              • Jan 2015
              • 2

              #7
              Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

              I suggest keep Madden 25

              Comment

              • taosixbbs
                Just started!
                • Jan 2015
                • 2

                #8
                Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                think so, M25 and M15 are the best Maddens we've seen in the X360/PS3 era.

                Comment

                • T3chNik4
                  Just started!
                  • Apr 2014
                  • 6

                  #9
                  Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                  This is just my opinion so don't call me out on this. But they are both the same game with Madden 15 adding a few features with an updated roster. I just went to the online communities and downloaded the latest roster for my Madden 25 rather than dishing out $60 for the same game and I noticed a slim difference between the two. Yeah, the defense and A.I. has been improved and there's new tackles and everything but I still don't see a point in paying $60 for the same game when I can pay $60 for something else.

                  Comment

                  • Art01
                    Pro
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 684

                    #10
                    Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                    Originally posted by T3chNik4
                    This is just my opinion so don't call me out on this. But they are both the same game with Madden 15 adding a few features with an updated roster. I just went to the online communities and downloaded the latest roster for my Madden 25 rather than dishing out $60 for the same game and I noticed a slim difference between the two. Yeah, the defense and A.I. has been improved and there's new tackles and everything but I still don't see a point in paying $60 for the same game when I can pay $60 for something else.
                    If you are on a 360, would you Zip the Latest Roster you downloaded for Madden 25 and attach the zip file to a new post in this thread? I do not have access to XBOX Live for Madden, thus I cannot download this Roster.
                    Roll Tide

                    Comment

                    • T3chNik4
                      Just started!
                      • Apr 2014
                      • 6

                      #11
                      Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                      Originally posted by Art01
                      If you are on a 360, would you Zip the Latest Roster you downloaded for Madden 25 and attach the zip file to a new post in this thread? I do not have access to XBOX Live for Madden, thus I cannot download this Roster.
                      I'm not exactly sure how I could do this... You mean by putting a USB drive in my Xbox and transferring the file to my computer and uploading the file here? If so, the only problem I have is my drive disappeared yet once again.

                      Comment

                      • Art01
                        Pro
                        • Sep 2007
                        • 684

                        #12
                        Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                        Originally posted by T3chNik4
                        I'm not exactly sure how I could do this... You mean by putting a USB drive in my Xbox and transferring the file to my computer and uploading the file here? If so, the only problem I have is my drive disappeared yet once again.
                        If you want to share a Roster by means other than uploading into the Madden Roster Share site (Gold Level required for access), then yes, you must format a flash drive in your 360, then use the System section of the 360 to copy the Roster to the flash drive. Flash Drives formatted in a 360 will not be recognized by Windows, so you would need a program such as Horizon or Modio on your PC to be able to transfer the Roster file to your PC. Once the file is on your PC, you can zip it and email it or attach it to a forum post.

                        Since I wrote my request, I have obtained a converted Madden 15 Roster from another thread in the Madden Last Gen Roster Forum. This file was converted from Madden 15 to Madden 25 and posted in a zip file.

                        Thanks for your reply.
                        Roll Tide

                        Comment

                        • IAmEMM
                          Rookie
                          • Jan 2015
                          • 45

                          #13
                          Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                          M15 is slightly better

                          Comment

                          • Ian Iachimoe
                            Rookie
                            • Oct 2012
                            • 161

                            #14
                            Re: Which is better: Keep Madden 25 or go for Madden 15?

                            I had the repeating draft class problem in 25 so it was an easy choice for me.

                            agree with jhobbins.

                            Comment

                            • tommi114
                              Just started!
                              • Jan 2015
                              • 7

                              #15
                              The best and cheapest authentic jerseys you have ever seen!

                              The best and cheapest authentic jerseys you have ever seen!
                              Cheap jersey and very nice quality NFL Jersey just need $18.99
                              Order 10 pcs jerseys we provide free shipping.
                              Share our site on Facebook you can get the 5% discount code!~
                              We also have the customized jersey service and you can have the jersey stitched on you name and your number!
                              Enjoy the best online shipping experience
                              www.efl-jerseys.com

                              Comment

                              Working...