Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • amoccia
    Rookie
    • Feb 2012
    • 123

    #1

    Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

    Hello all. I currently have Xbox one and PS3 and own all the games above. I like to do an analysis of the three. I hope this helps individuals when deciding to buy these games.

    Nba live 16. I own it for Xbox one. Graphics are decent but not great. Way better than previous versions. But that is not saying much. Arenas look great and ESPN integration is cool. However still have weird animations. Still kinda Arcady and to not have injuries in played games makes no sense to me in a 82 game season. Very average game but fun for people who are just looking to play with simple controls and good graphics. I got it for free bc I traded in games so I was cool with it


    2k 16 Xbox one. Really good game. Hard core sim. Injuries graphics arenas deep association mode. Here's the problem. It is not simple and I found myself not enjoying it bc it was too involved. U have to be able to devote time to adjust to things understand things etc. and it is not a perfect game. Still have Some issues but I see why people enjoy it. Much better than live but more involved


    2k16 ps3. Okay. So I only expected updated rosters and schedules. However it is way more than that. The graphics of the players are way different. Basically like current gen like in 14 on 2k. I use the Knicks. Melo and kp are spot on. They just updated Galloway and he looks spot on. Of course some players are better looking than others. All the menus have changed ratings screens have changed faster load times. Pretty much a whole new game. Driving to hoop is harder new rim animations.



    Bottom line I like PS3 version the best. I am strictly an offline player but if anyone had questions on offline aspects of these games to help make a decision I can do that for u. If ur in to graphics and presentation than 2k for Xbox is for u if u have time for it. Otherwise I recommend the PS3 version bc it is a completely different experience from 15 in my opinion
  • FOXHOUNDxBigBoss
    Rookie
    • Jun 2014
    • 272

    #2
    Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

    Did they fix Jordan Clarkson's skin color yet? On 10/11 update his skin color didn't match his face. I haven't been able to get online on my ps3 in a few days.

    Comment

    • amoccia
      Rookie
      • Feb 2012
      • 123

      #3
      Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

      Sorry fox. I haven't been online in awhile either. My last check was when they updated him and Galloway. I only checked once since then and he looked the same

      Comment

      • Oaklandboy
        MVP
        • Jan 2012
        • 1183

        #4
        Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

        I have it on Xbox 360 and I love it. They just didn't fix the shoes and some players cf

        Sent from my HTC Desire 626s using Tapatalk

        Comment

        • Danbo80
          Rookie
          • Jul 2002
          • 185

          #5
          Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

          For PS3/360, Have there been any improvements to the sim engine, sim stats specifically? Are league leaders in rebounds and assists still to low?

          Comment

          • Leasim96
            Pro
            • Oct 2014
            • 948

            #6
            Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

            Originally posted by Danbo80
            For PS3/360, Have there been any improvements to the sim engine, sim stats specifically? Are league leaders in rebounds and assists still to low?
            I already adressed this in my review here

            Comment

            • Oaklandboy
              MVP
              • Jan 2012
              • 1183

              #7
              Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

              Originally posted by Leasim96
              I already adressed this in my review here
              Is there going to be any shoe updates like 2k15. And Cyberface updates

              Sent from my HTC Desire 626s using Tapatalk

              Comment

              • Jordanmike6
                Rookie
                • Nov 2014
                • 417

                #8
                Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                Are the naturelly triangle offense better?
                Is it still the same playbook for the classic Bulls? 12 swingpost, 32 punch, 31 cross up 14 reverse iso 42 up strong 52 roll 35 strong post, 12 Quick iso, 54 over etc etc
                How is the game play because i prefere 2k11 or 2k12 or 13 but i don't like the 15 impossible to control your player with the ball....

                Comment

                • Leasim96
                  Pro
                  • Oct 2014
                  • 948

                  #9
                  Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                  Originally posted by Oaklandboy
                  Is there going to be any shoe updates like 2k15. And Cyberface updates

                  Sent from my HTC Desire 626s using Tapatalk
                  Cyberface updates there have already been a few

                  Shoe updates i could honestly care less, but probably.

                  Comment

                  • Leasim96
                    Pro
                    • Oct 2014
                    • 948

                    #10
                    Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                    Originally posted by Jordanmike6
                    Are the naturelly triangle offense better?
                    Is it still the same playbook for the classic Bulls? 12 swingpost, 32 punch, 31 cross up 14 reverse iso 42 up strong 52 roll 35 strong post, 12 Quick iso, 54 over etc etc
                    How is the game play because i prefere 2k11 or 2k12 or 13 but i don't like the 15 impossible to control your player with the ball....
                    The gameplay is WAY better to me, the best it has ever been, read my review here on the forums for more on that.

                    Comment

                    • Oaklandboy
                      MVP
                      • Jan 2012
                      • 1183

                      #11
                      Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                      Originally posted by Leasim96
                      The gameplay is WAY better to me, the best it has ever been, read my review here on the forums for more on that.
                      I think they should at least give last gen a couple of updates.

                      Sent from my HTC Desire 626s using Tapatalk

                      Comment

                      • Leasim96
                        Pro
                        • Oct 2014
                        • 948

                        #12
                        Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                        Originally posted by Oaklandboy
                        I think they should at least give last gen a couple of updates.

                        Sent from my HTC Desire 626s using Tapatalk
                        They have given tons already compared to 2k15, the game is the best it has ever been

                        To think it will be ps4 quality is ignorant, we have to understand the limitatios that come to play BEFORE, we buy the game, its an era where last gen users must be open minded and grateful for what they can still have at the least, or simply not buy the game at all and simply move on

                        I for one am very satisfied so far and have been impressed with the changes from 2k15 to 2k16

                        Comment

                        • amoccia
                          Rookie
                          • Feb 2012
                          • 123

                          #13
                          Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                          I agree between graphics and gameplay and complete redesign of menus etc. this is the best it will ever get. Sadly if any more games are made for nba 2k it will probably just roster update and updated schedules bc I am not sure what more they can get out of last generation version. I also fully agree that if anyway expects anything different going forward than don't purchase game and move on

                          Comment

                          • Jordanmike6
                            Rookie
                            • Nov 2014
                            • 417

                            #14
                            Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                            You know, i played to 2k11 yesterday and graphics are way better that on next gen. Don't to people to move on guy, please be nice.
                            Thanks.
                            And answer me about naturraly triangle.
                            You could show us a beautiful video of the 96 Bulls at charlotte 93!!

                            Don't say that curent gen couldn't get better graphics because the business make the next gen arriving earlier not the power of the ps3!!!

                            Comment

                            • amoccia
                              Rookie
                              • Feb 2012
                              • 123

                              #15
                              Re: Nba 2k16 PS3 vs nba 2k Xbox one vs nba live 16

                              All I meant by moving on was that if ur looking for amazing graphics over gameplay than PS3 is not for you bc I feel next generation focuses on presentation and misses out and doesn't directly address gameplay therefore gameplay isn't as good.
                              Nba 2k16 for PS3 has always had better gameplay than current gen and didn't change the menus or graphics in years. They have done all of that in this version which is great this late in the consoles cycle. I am extremely happy with this version and haven't picked up the Xbox one version I own since I briefly played it when i purchased it.

                              Also it would be wonderful if they continue to add new features to the PS3 version but just like ps2 eventually it was just a repackaged game i.e. 2k12 with updated rosters. Finally I don't use classic teams so I don't know about the classic Bulls and their playbook

                              Comment

                              Working...