2015 Sports Game of the Year: Best Gameplay

[RaychelSnr]

Ah yes gameplay. The nuts and bolts of how a game actually plays on the field, ice, pitch, track, etc. (when it comes to sports games at least). Everything from how the game controls, to its realism, to its balance encompasses gameplay. In 2015, gameplay was an almost universally high quality amongst sports games. That meant picking winners was a little difficult...

Read More - 2015 Sports Game of the Year: Best Gameplay

[misterkrabz]

I don't get the fascination with the NBA 2K Franchise. To me, the controls are clunky and confusing. The control scheme it'self seems like a confusing maze of button and stick combinations to navigate to get the player you're controlling to do the simplest maneuver. Even the game menus are confusing. I buy into the hype about every other year and pick the game up and every other year I play it a handful of times (maybe a half dozen 10-15 minutes play sessions) and never touch it again. I usually play the cpu and turn the game off before the first game is over...I let it sit then come back to it a couple weeks later and do the same thing over again. It could be that I just don't have the patience to learn the complex control scheme but it seems to me much of this game could be way more intuitive. And I'm talking everything from performing moves on the court to making substitutions in game.

[jaynral]

EA should be ashamed that Madden didint make this list..they have no competition, the most finances, the most resources and its the best sport in america....Terrible...Well deserved for the 3 winners!!!

[misterkrabz]

I would argue that Madden is better (game play wise) than two of the games on this list, sales figures would probably validate that as well....MLB being the best for sure. I own all of these games, including rocket league and can say I've played this years Madden and MLB more than any other other game I've ever bought...and that's going back 30 years. I'm really stoked about the current state of my favorite sports (baseball-football). We're getting to the stage of gaming evolution where they're not battling things like lag and game options (leagues/online play/game modes/ect.) but are to the point where they are fine tuning details of game play. If MLB can figure a better system for holding runners on/stealing and implement some player collision detection in the field they'll have that sport nailed. As it is I'm happy with what we have.

[statum71]

I'm sure Rocket League is a cool game. But what "sport" is that again?

[ChaseB]

I'm sure Rocket League is a cool game. But what "sport" is that again?

NASCAR Soccer.

[tril]

this is the fist year that I disagree with the choice.
2k this year is frustrating in a bad way.
there were too many changes to the control schems this year. some which were down right awful, play calling and subbing players come to mind.
and did they get rid of the box out feature for rebounding?
and where's the defense. defense. some folks like defense. like playing defense. this includes team defense.

the game is still good but not as good as some of the versions from years past. (2k15 is my favorite followed by 2k11) IMO< 2k16 is beautiful to look at, and presentation are what shine, not the gameplay.

Id give the title to MLB the Show. the commentary is the only issue, but I believe that is on purpose. The commentary is purposefully bland, cause I believe they are trying to capture that lazy Saturday afternoon baseball feel. iid still like to see amjor overhaul though, to give the presentation more life.

[Semipro91]

this is the fist year that I disagree with the choice.
2k this year is frustrating in a bad way.
there were too many changes to the control schems this year. some which were down right awful, play calling and subbing players come to mind.
and did they get rid of the box out feature for rebounding?
and where's the defense. defense. some folks like defense. like playing defense. this includes team defense.

the game is still good but not as good as some of the versions from years past. (2k15 is my favorite followed by 2k11) IMO< 2k16 is beautiful to look at, and presentation are what shine, not the gameplay.

Id give the title to MLB the Show. the commentary is the only issue, but I believe that is on purpose. The commentary is purposefully bland, cause I believe they are trying to capture that lazy Saturday afternoon baseball feel. iid still like to see amjor overhaul though, to give the presentation more life.

You might be confused with a different NBA title. 2K16 has some flaws but it is by far, the best Defensive Basketball game to date.

[tril]

You might be confused with a different NBA title. 2K16 has some flaws but it is by far, the best Defensive Basketball game to date.

you might be right. Ive watched videos etc, and defense still breaks down consistently. especially the transition defense. if you can point me to some videos or tutorials on how to play defense. Id appreciate it.

I hate being hard on 2k. cause Im such a 2k fanboy.

[JasonLin]

I don't like the gameplay of NBA 2K16, the shot stick control is 100 times worse than NBA 2K14 era. It's unresponsive, inaccurate and often does things that you don't want to see.

[Badasi12b]

"NBA 2K16 is a game that is enriching both offline and online"
That comment right there! This is why I can't take 2k16 praise seriously! The game is overrated. Haven't played it online because I can't yet. But that's how I know noone has seriously played this game offline yet and reviewed it. I had to sale the game because unlike nba live 16 (which I bought after selling 2k16) the game borders on unplayable offline! The retail case needs a buyer beware warning saying ONLINE REQUIRED! The game literally doesn't save ANYTHING if you play offline! It's a glorified demo and everything is either limited or locked! The only thing available to play if you're offline is play now or blacktop. NO REVIEWS MENTION THIS! So misleading and dishonest. I may not ever buy another 2k again.

[Badasi12b]

I don't get the fascination with the NBA 2K Franchise. To me, the controls are clunky and confusing. The control scheme it'self seems like a confusing maze of button and stick combinations to navigate to get the player you're controlling to do the simplest maneuver. Even the game menus are confusing. I buy into the hype about every other year and pick the game up and every other year I play it a handful of times (maybe a half dozen 10-15 minutes play sessions) and never touch it again. I usually play the cpu and turn the game off before the first game is over...I let it sit then come back to it a couple weeks later and do the same thing over again. It could be that I just don't have the patience to learn the complex control scheme but it seems to me much of this game could be way more intuitive. And I'm talking everything from performing moves on the court to making substitutions in game.

I played three games of it before I decided to return it. I was only into the presentation.

[DJ]

Re: 2015 Sports Game of the Year: Best Gameplay

"NBA 2K16 is a game that is enriching both offline and online"
That comment right there! This is why I can't take 2k16 praise seriously! The game is overrated. Haven't played it online because I can't yet. But that's how I know noone has seriously played this game offline yet and reviewed it. I had to sale the game because unlike nba live 16 (which I bought after selling 2k16) the game borders on unplayable offline! The retail case needs a buyer beware warning saying ONLINE REQUIRED! The game literally doesn't save ANYTHING if you play offline! It's a glorified demo and everything is either limited or locked! The only thing available to play if you're offline is play now or blacktop. NO REVIEWS MENTION THIS! So misleading and dishonest. I may not ever buy another 2k again.

You have to let the game download and install first. All modes are available to you after that is complete, not sure what was going on with your copy.

I prefer 2K15 to 16, but 16 is still very good. I thought Madden deserved a spot in the Top 3.

[NELL86]

2k16 best gameplay??? I want what y'all smoking smh

[tril]

2k16 best gameplay??? I want what y'all smoking smh

cosign... stop lieing to us...
the game is pretty and the presentation is top notch.
but again that defense.
I dont care what anyone says the defense does not work as intended........Ive watched tutorials, made adjustments. again, it doesnt work as intended.
Ive never rage quit this much in a 2k game. its Madden like