Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

I probably will stay with 17. I like 16 better but since I uninstalled 16 and changed my password the Patch 1.09 did not fixed auto baserunning problems. B4 the uninstalled BR worked perfectly, ???

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

no way not even a question. I am still in the Hollywood phase of mlb the show 17

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

I'm curious what their daily active users looks like compared to the same time last year.

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

my son recently bought a ps4 and i HAD to get mlb the show....i went with 16 because it was cheaper (which i actually got for $7.99 due to a pricing error). i am more than pleased for a few reasons. cheaper, of course...some great classic team rosters were already in place since the game has been out for some time...current and world baseball classic rosters too...love diamond dynasty and created the defunct montreal expos (using just free agents for an additional challenge). don't see a need for 17, for the time being.

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

Not even a little bit.

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

I've spent a great deal of time over the last 2 weeks playing the original Show for ps4 (MLB 14) and while I dont prefer it, or 16 for that matter, over 17, it has been a nice change of pace. IMO 14 holds up well 3 years later though I was mainly playing it because of the default roster and to take a break from what I have going on in 17. I think come late August I will pop in Show 15 and relive those rosters for a bit too.

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

Before they nerfed hitting in that patch, my answer would be no.

Re: Anybody prefer MLB The Show 16 over 17
 

I play 90% franchise mode and while there are some changes in 17 that I think are terrible and the overall mode really hasn't changed going back multiple games, the game play is why I prefer 17 to 16. Yes it is not what I would call a polished game (seems like they rushed 17 and didn't finish it honestly), changes to game physics make game play that much more enjoyable and that's what it is really about for me.