This is NBA Live

[RayRay34]

I just have to say that this is by far my favorite Live ever and it is turning into one of my favorite basketball games ever. Sure, it still has some faults and it's not feature rich, but what EA has done with the gameplay and making a game not only fun but somewhat realistic is awesome. I honestly hope the fact the it's not a 2k product doesn't stop people from checking this game out. This is honestly in my opinion a step in the right direction for Live basketball. I've been playing the EA access trial for about 7 of my 10 hours and I can't wait until Friday to continue my experience with the game. As someone who has played every NBA basketball game ever made I just want to say thank you EA. Great job on this game and continue to make it better.

[ClassicMan]

Re: This is NBA Live

I was quite surprised when i played the demo 3 or 4 weeks ago, i knew 18 would be good but not THIS GOOD! Lol

Sent from my SM-G925T using Tapatalk

[Whomario]

Re: This is NBA Live

Saying it is "not feature rich" is a huge understatement. The Franchise Mode is straight out of like 2005.

I am also not a fan of the "auto-movement" that goes on in gameplay, where you get locked into moving several yards where you can't control your player.

But yeah, step in the right direction.

[Cavs2016]

Re: This is NBA Live

Saying it is "not feature rich" is a huge understatement. The Franchise Mode is straight out of like 2005.

I am also not a fan of the "auto-movement" that goes on in gameplay, where you get locked into moving several yards where you can't control your player.

But yeah, step in the right direction.

The auto lock movement needs to be toned down. I think it should be easier to pull out of. Needs to be less sticky. Also the passing and contest buttons feel unresponsive and slow at times.

[Fist Of Kings]

Re: This is NBA Live

Saying it is "not feature rich" is a huge understatement. The Franchise Mode is straight out of like 2005.

I am also not a fan of the "auto-movement" that goes on in gameplay, where you get locked into moving several yards where you can't control your player.

But yeah, step in the right direction.

Yikes, that is troubling news. I was hoping dynasty mode would be surprisingly deep.

[Schrankwand]

Re: This is NBA Live

Yikes, that is troubling news. I was hoping dynasty mode would be surprisingly deep.

Nah, Live was never that crazy deep when it comes to dynasty/franchise mode. I am not really surprised in that department.

[seanhazz1]

Re: This is NBA Live

Nah, Live was never that crazy deep when it comes to dynasty/franchise mode. I am not really surprised in that department.

Franchise is almost a copy and paste of Madden(love it), without the online option. The menus are good and informative and it tracks stats and standings. People don't like the lack of a daily view in the calendar for matchups, or lack of editing within.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[extremeskins04]

Re: This is NBA Live

Franchise is almost a copy and paste of Madden(love it), without the online option. The menus are good and informative and it tracks stats and standings. People don't like the lack of a daily view in the calendar for matchups, or lack of editing within.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

The major problems with Live 18's franchise mode are:

1. Franchise is now separated into weeks instead of days, meaning the simulation of CPU games and transactions only occurs when a week is advanced rather than on a typical daily schedule. This works for Madden cause it's on a weekly game schedule, but not for an NBA game.

2. There is a fake player named Alan Hinners that is in every franchise mode and he's a rookie made available in free agency at the start of the 1st season. He has an All-Star rating of 90 (AS A ROOKIE!) and is always picked up by the Mavericks and always wins Rookie of the Year in every franchise. He averages 25 ppg and 12 apg.

3. The simulation engine is pretty broken. The first season of simming the season, the Miami Heat beat the Memphis Grizzlies in the Finals. Thinking this was just an anomaly, it wasn't. After several simulations of seasons, the Knicks, Mavericks, Clippers and Hornets all won championships. The Cavs rare even made it to the finals. Same with the Warriors. Celtics never made it.

4. The CPU does not complete any trades among the 29 teams that aren't being controlled.

5. There are no injuries that occur during games and only happens in simulations.

6. Turning off the auto-sub feature completely breaks the CPU, it won't substitute at all during games.

7. There's no online component to Franchise.

8. There's no ability to edit the players at all in Franchise mode.


This is actually worse than Madden to be honest. Madden already had a pretty bland (but serviceable) CFM mode, but Live isn't a step in the right direction IMO. It's 5 steps backwards.

[Americas Team]

Re: This is NBA Live

Franchise is almost a copy and paste of Madden(love it), without the online option. The menus are good and informative and it tracks stats and standings. People don't like the lack of a daily view in the calendar for matchups, or lack of editing within.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Madden isn't a very good Franchise example or template to follow, lol.

Sent from my BLN-L24 using Operation Sports mobile app

[Schrankwand]

Re: This is NBA Live

Franchise is almost a copy and paste of Madden(love it), without the online option. The menus are good and informative and it tracks stats and standings. People don't like the lack of a daily view in the calendar for matchups, or lack of editing within.

I also have absolutely no problem with Live being more simplistic when it comes to the Dynasty Mode. Just saw a couple of videos on how this mode is built up. Everything seems pretty basic, but i like the overall view. Nothing to complicated. It seems you can just jump in and have a good one. In 2k you need a little bit of time to get used to all the menus and little things you can do within that mode.

Well, 3 more days and i see it for myself. I don't play Madden, btw

[chelios7]

Re: This is NBA Live

Franchise mode is pretty broken. No trades, no injuries, stats are off, teams making the playoffs seem pretty random at times, etc...

I posted some pictures in the Impressions thread of the standings after a season along with some stat leaders. Warriors v Hornets for the title and the Hornets took the Warriors to 7. 76ers being a top 4 seed in both franchise years I simmed.

[MLBNFLNBALGS]

Re: This is NBA Live

The major problems with Live 18's franchise mode are:

1. Franchise is now separated into weeks instead of days, meaning the simulation of CPU games and transactions only occurs when a week is advanced rather than on a typical daily schedule. This works for Madden cause it's on a weekly game schedule, but not for an NBA game.

2. There is a fake player named Alan Hinners that is in every franchise mode and he's a rookie made available in free agency at the start of the 1st season. He has an All-Star rating of 90 (AS A ROOKIE!) and is always picked up by the Mavericks and always wins Rookie of the Year in every franchise. He averages 25 ppg and 12 apg.

3. The simulation engine is pretty broken. The first season of simming the season, the Miami Heat beat the Memphis Grizzlies in the Finals. Thinking this was just an anomaly, it wasn't. After several simulations of seasons, the Knicks, Mavericks, Clippers and Hornets all won championships. The Cavs rare even made it to the finals. Same with the Warriors. Celtics never made it.

4. The CPU does not complete any trades among the 29 teams that aren't being controlled.

5. There are no injuries that occur during games and only happens in simulations.

6. Turning off the auto-sub feature completely breaks the CPU, it won't substitute at all during games.

7. There's no online component to Franchise.

8. There's no ability to edit the players at all in Franchise mode.


This is actually worse than Madden to be honest. Madden already had a pretty bland (but serviceable) CFM mode, but Live isn't a step in the right direction IMO. It's 5 steps backwards.

Now I see why there's no ONLINE CFM.... Whenever they decide to make games like they use to, they'll regain that capital! Shouldn't be this way...

[coachcolbert]

Re: This is NBA Live

Franchise is almost a copy and paste of Madden(love it), without the online option. The menus are good and informative and it tracks stats and standings. People don't like the lack of a daily view in the calendar for matchups, or lack of editing within.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

i like to hear this. for me, i kinda like the simplicity. i like maddens cfm but i also havent bought madden since madden25 before buying madden 18.

i do get why some people are disapointed though. if i was strictly a franchise guy id want more too.

i heard LUT was pretty stripped down as well. hopefully after this year getting gameplay to be respected again they will focus more on the other modes in the future

Sent from my SM-N910V using Operation Sports mobile app

[coachcolbert]

Re: This is NBA Live

The major problems with Live 18's franchise mode are:

1. Franchise is now separated into weeks instead of days, meaning the simulation of CPU games and transactions only occurs when a week is advanced rather than on a typical daily schedule. This works for Madden cause it's on a weekly game schedule, but not for an NBA game.

2. There is a fake player named Alan Hinners that is in every franchise mode and he's a rookie made available in free agency at the start of the 1st season. He has an All-Star rating of 90 (AS A ROOKIE!) and is always picked up by the Mavericks and always wins Rookie of the Year in every franchise. He averages 25 ppg and 12 apg.

3. The simulation engine is pretty broken. The first season of simming the season, the Miami Heat beat the Memphis Grizzlies in the Finals. Thinking this was just an anomaly, it wasn't. After several simulations of seasons, the Knicks, Mavericks, Clippers and Hornets all won championships. The Cavs rare even made it to the finals. Same with the Warriors. Celtics never made it.

4. The CPU does not complete any trades among the 29 teams that aren't being controlled.

5. There are no injuries that occur during games and only happens in simulations.

6. Turning off the auto-sub feature completely breaks the CPU, it won't substitute at all during games.

7. There's no online component to Franchise.

8. There's no ability to edit the players at all in Franchise mode.


This is actually worse than Madden to be honest. Madden already had a pretty bland (but serviceable) CFM mode, but Live isn't a step in the right direction IMO. It's 5 steps backwards.

damn lol, @extremeskins04 - you laid it all out!

i feel the guys that are primarily franchise guys and are looking for a more fleshed out mode. i really do!

Sent from my SM-N910V using Operation Sports mobile app