Best Roster for MyLeague?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DanBeats71
    Rookie
    • Oct 2012
    • 20

    #1

    Best Roster for MyLeague?

    Hi all,

    Looking for some advice - I'm after the most accurate, immersive roster for using in a MyLeague, any ideas? I'm not too bothered about having all the latest trades, e.g. KP to Mavs, etc. but equipment, attributes, rotations, playbooks, etc. would ideally be close to real life. Is the Official 2K roster the best for this? Or is there a custom one that is head and shoulders above the rest?

    Thanks in advance.
  • Funkycorm
    Cleveland Baseball Guru
    • Nov 2016
    • 3160

    #2
    Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

    I personally stick with the official 2k rosters. There are multiple roster creators that put a lot of work into their rosters and I respect that, but none ever feel right to me. This is from trying different ones out over multiple NBA 2k games.

    My 2 cents is the official 2k ones but it wouldn't hurt to try others. They might feel right for you.
    Last edited by Funkycorm; 02-07-2019, 03:33 PM.
    Funkycorm

    Currently Playing:

    MLB The Show 25 (PS5)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
    Pokemon Violet (Switch)


    Twitch:

    Twitch


    Dynasties:

    None at the moment

    Comment

    • Chederer
      Rookie
      • Sep 2018
      • 136

      #3
      Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

      The fact that funkycorm said that makes me think he's an actual employee of 2k, haha. The 2k Rosters are trash. Indisputably bad in almost every conceivable way. Ratings are off, tendencies are way way off for almost every single player. They famously didn't get Luka Doncic's position or height right in this game. The no-doubt rookie of the year in the NBA had both his position and height wrong.



      If you're on ps4, the attention to detail roster for ps4 is amazing, it tries to combine all the work that other people have done into one big roster file.

      Comment

      • Funkycorm
        Cleveland Baseball Guru
        • Nov 2016
        • 3160

        #4
        Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

        Originally posted by Chederer
        The fact that funkycorm said that makes me think he's an actual employee of 2k, haha. The 2k Rosters are trash. Indisputably bad in almost every conceivable way. Ratings are off, tendencies are way way off for almost every single player. They famously didn't get Luka Doncic's position or height right in this game. The no-doubt rookie of the year in the NBA had both his position and height wrong.



        If you're on ps4, the attention to detail roster for ps4 is amazing, it tries to combine all the work that other people have done into one big roster file.
        LOL. Nah. My thing is that I play 1 game, sim 4-5, play 1 sim 4-5. This means I get multiple seasons into a franchise. Badges that were removed from players start being earned by current players or by rookie classes coming in. I edit my own draft classes to a point, mostly for age and a few odd things the draft class generator does. But I prefer randomly generated classes. Changes the feel of the league for each dynasty.

        I never said I love the 2k rosters, I said I stick with them. I don't disagree they are sub par. Trust me, I edited Luka and a few other players first thing.

        The attention to detail rosters are good. Never said they weren't. But like I said, the way I play, they don't feel right. It's also why I suggested he try others.
        Funkycorm

        Currently Playing:

        MLB The Show 25 (PS5)
        Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
        Pokemon Violet (Switch)


        Twitch:

        Twitch


        Dynasties:

        None at the moment

        Comment

        • YogurtProducer
          Pro
          • Sep 2012
          • 508

          #5
          Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

          Originally posted by Funkycorm
          LOL. Nah. My thing is that I play 1 game, sim 4-5, play 1 sim 4-5. This means I get multiple seasons into a franchise. Badges that were removed from players start being earned by current players or by rookie classes coming in. I edit my own draft classes to a point, mostly for age and a few odd things the draft class generator does. But I prefer randomly generated classes. Changes the feel of the league for each dynasty.

          I never said I love the 2k rosters, I said I stick with them. I don't disagree they are sub par. Trust me, I edited Luka and a few other players first thing.

          The attention to detail rosters are good. Never said they weren't. But like I said, the way I play, they don't feel right. It's also why I suggested he try others.
          AKA, this guys cheeses and good rosters limit that

          Comment

          • Bunselpower32
            Pro
            • Jul 2012
            • 947

            #6
            Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

            To get back on topic, I love the Attention to Detail roster. He has a lot of tendencies that the main roster leaves out that bear out over a season. Combined with Schnaidt's Gameplay and MyLeague sliders, you have a real nice 5-year franchise experience. Unfortunately with progression being what it is you can't go too much farther than that with ultra-realistic results, but for the vast majority it's plenty.

            He is currently working on an updated version that I am anxiously awaiting to start my own MyLeague.
            "The designated hitter rule is like letting someone else take Wilt Chamberlain's free throws."

            - Rick Wise

            Comment

            • vtcrb
              Hall Of Fame
              • Nov 2006
              • 10297

              #7
              Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

              I have a Fictional MyLeague Roster on Xbox if you are looking for something different. Everything is edited including Playbooks & Peak Ages.
              NBA 2k18 Roster:
              http://forums.operationsports.com/vt...okies-xboxone/




              Twitter: @VTCRBTEC

              Youtube Channel:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKL...1uva35l4zFEofg

              Roster Editing for Over a Decade

              Comment

              • sharkwalk2000
                Just started!
                • Feb 2019
                • 3

                #8
                Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

                What's the name of your fictional myleague roster on xbone?

                Comment

                • Shuayb11AC
                  Rookie
                  • Dec 2017
                  • 22

                  #9
                  Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

                  Sorry to go slightly off topic but could a Moderator or veteran member PM me,

                  I've been working on a roster of my own but don't have the access to make a new thread to share it with you all, being fairly new to using these forums.

                  Comment

                  • vtcrb
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Nov 2006
                    • 10297

                    #10
                    Re: Best Roster for MyLeague?

                    Originally posted by sharkwalk2000
                    What's the name of your fictional myleague roster on xbone?
                    Trifecta Fictional MyLeague
                    NBA 2k18 Roster:
                    http://forums.operationsports.com/vt...okies-xboxone/




                    Twitter: @VTCRBTEC

                    Youtube Channel:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKL...1uva35l4zFEofg

                    Roster Editing for Over a Decade

                    Comment

                    Working...