Also, before each game go into settings and turn illegal man downfield penalty to ON.
Try these sliders and give feedback.
Game Settings: Set in Main Menu
Difficulty: All Madden
Simulation Style
15 min quarters
Accelerated Clock On
Clock Run Down: 12 seconds
Injuries: 50
Fatigue: 50
Min Player Speed Threshold: 50
Leave Human/CPU Sliders at Default
Reset Sliders then manually set in CFM
Slider Settings (Human/CPU)
QB Accuracy: 25
Pass Blocking: 55
WR Catching: 50
Run Block: 55
Fumbles: 50
Pass Defense: 50
Interceptions: 45
Pass Coverage: 50
Tackling: 50
Injury: 50
Fatigue: 60
Min Player Speed Threshold: 50
Special Teams Default 50
Penalties:
Illegal Man down field: On
(Must turn on in game before kickoff)
Offsides: 60
False Start: 60
Holding: 85
Facemask: 51
Def PI: 85
Block in the Back: 55
Rough Pass: 51
Rough Pass: 51
Offensive PI: Off
Kick Catch Interference: Off
Intentional Gounding: Off
Roughing the Kicker: On
Running into the Kicker: On

Comment