Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • atlwarya
    Rookie
    • Jun 2005
    • 336

    #1

    Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

    Every Roster Requires a certain slider set. Some of them can use the defaults, and some cannot. That doesn’t make any better than the other. Since we have only one NBA game, it is easy to get bored of using the same type of roster, so you’ll have to switch it up sometimes. You might even want to experiment with different sliders. 2k has the best slider community. Here’s a list of some of the best Roster and Slider combinations…

    2K Default Rosters: POPBOY Sliders, DEFAULT SLIDER SETS, SCHNAIDTS 4th set and SHADYMIKE. I don’t have to go into much detail. They are the defaults. People bash 2k’s roster but they are better than most people think. This year they have been doing a great job in comparison to previous years. (Changed due to patches)

    Real2Kinsider: has been doing rosters since 2K3 I think. His formula is the same as 2k default but he’s more detailed, so I tested a few sliders with his roster. The best slider sets with his are definitely the DEFAULT SETS, POPBOY Sliders, and SHADYMIKES. SCHNAIDTS 4th set are great as well with the game speed set to 60. My personal choice is SHADYMIKES for this set. The defaults don’t give you enough 3 pointers. Myleague is amazing with his roster btw on the Shadymikes or DEFAULT settings. He has every position change, contract, heights, transactions, and badges updated. The only downside is that they are only on PS4. (Changed due to patches)

    CelticLG ATD: They really defy the 2k formula but I love it. It makes the gameplay amazing. You really need sliders for it to work. SCHNAIDTS ATD slider set gives you probably the most sim gameplay experience ever. The ratings are a little questionable at times but I don’t care as long as it brings the perfect sim experience, and it does just that. ECCENTRICMEAT makes ATD sliders as well and they are great. The drive camera is not for me personally but I use the broadcast. He has made sliders for years and always delivers in sim style of play. JSIMKITS sliders play really well with this roster as well and his sliders are SHOT TIMING! His sliders work for both PS4 and PS5!

    Nogster: This guy has been around a while too. He does everything like ATD. He really goes into detail with ratings and tendencies. and is a sleeper on the list. He uses 2k’s formula but is strict with his overalls. The gameplay is for more advanced 2k users as well because I always get my *** kicked with his rosters. That’s what makes them fun. The best sets with his rosters are the DEFAULT SETS. You can also use POPBOYS. It will help to increase the 3 pointers.

    TYNOLE: one of my personal favorites on PS5. He also like ATD has an unorthodox way of doing his edits. But it works for the gameplay experience. He knows basketball. You can tell how he breaks down his videos on YouTube. He also updates the playbooks. The best sliders to go with his set is his own slider set. He not only did rating edits and tendencies, but he did sig shots, equipment, and appearance too. He has Melo with the braids. He has Claxton with black dreads. Idk how he accomplished that. But yeah his roster sliders provide a more uptempo style of play. It’s a lot like todays nba. A lot of 3s. The cpu will shoot up to 30-40 3s.

    These are my guide on how to get the best slider experience on each roster.




    Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
    Last edited by atlwarya; 02-09-2022, 02:17 AM.
  • Teleo
    MVP
    • Nov 2013
    • 2302

    #2
    Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

    Awesome write up 👍🏻

    Comment

    • atlwarya
      Rookie
      • Jun 2005
      • 336

      #3
      Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

      Thanks I just want for people to know how to get the best out of each roster. I will keep analyzing different roster and slider combos that work.


      Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

      Comment

      • COMMISSIONERHBK9
        MVP
        • Dec 2003
        • 4564

        #4
        Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

        Originally posted by atlwarya
        Thanks I just want for people to know how to get the best out of each roster. I will keep analyzing different roster and slider combos that work.


        Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
        Great write up. Question which rosters do you use for your gameplay and if u do use atd do you use real fg or do u use shot timing
        Check out my YouTube page

        https://www.youtube.com/@mr_too_soon

        https://twitter.com/Mr_too_soon

        Comment

        • BleacherCreature
          MVP
          • Apr 2007
          • 3160

          #5
          Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

          For anyone using Real2kInsider’s rosters they are accurate including the Knicks/Hawks trade from yesterday.


          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

          Comment

          • COMMISSIONERHBK9
            MVP
            • Dec 2003
            • 4564

            #6
            Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

            Originally posted by BleacherCreature
            For anyone using Real2kInsider’s rosters they are accurate including the Knicks/Hawks trade from yesterday.


            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
            What system is real2k roster on
            Check out my YouTube page

            https://www.youtube.com/@mr_too_soon

            https://twitter.com/Mr_too_soon

            Comment

            • BleacherCreature
              MVP
              • Apr 2007
              • 3160

              #7
              Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

              Originally posted by COMMISSIONERHBK9
              What system is real2k roster on

              PS4


              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

              Comment

              • Damis
                Rookie
                • Jan 2022
                • 11

                #8
                Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                Originally posted by atlwarya
                Every Roster Requires a certain slider set. Some of them can use the defaults, and some cannot. That doesn’t make any better than the other. Since we have only one NBA game, it is easy to get bored of using the same type of roster, so you’ll have to switch it up sometimes. You might even want to experiment with different sliders. 2k has the best slider community. Here’s a list of some of the best Roster and Slider combinations…

                2K Default Rosters: DEFAULT SLIDER SETS, POPBOYS, SCHNAIDTS 4th set and SHADYMIKE. I don’t have to go into much detail. They are the defaults. People bash 2k’s roster but they are better than most people think. This year they have been doing a great job in comparison to previous years.

                Real2Kinsider: has been doing rosters since 2K3 I think. His formula is the same as 2k default but he’s more detailed, so I tested a few sliders with his roster. The best slider sets with his are definitely the DEFAULT SETS and POPBOYS. SCHNAIDTS 4th set are great as well with the game speed set to 60. My personal choice is POPBOYS for this set. The defaults don’t give you enough 3 pointers. POPBOYS set are the most similar to the default set but fixed. Myleague is amazing with his roster btw on the POPBOYS or DEFAULT settings. He has every position change, contract, heights, transactions, and badges updated. The only downside is that they are only on PS4

                CelticLG ATD: They really defy the 2k formula but I love it. It makes the gameplay amazing. You really need sliders for it to work. SCHNAIDTS ATD slider set gives you probably the most sim gameplay experience ever. The ratings are a little questionable at times but I don’t care as long as it brings the perfect sim experience, and it does just that. ECCENTRICMEAT makes ATD sliders as well and they are great. The drive camera is not for me personally but I use the broadcast. He has made sliders for years and always delivers in sim style of play.

                Nogster: This guy has been around a while too. He does everything like ATD. He really goes into detail with ratings and tendencies. and is a sleeper on the list. He uses 2k’s formula but is strict with his overalls. The gameplay is for more advanced 2k users as well because I always get my *** kicked with his rosters. That’s what makes them fun. The best sets with his rosters are the DEFAULT SETS. You can also use POPBOYS. It will help to increase the 3 pointers.

                TYNOLE: one of my personal favorites on PS5. He also like ATD has an unorthodox way of doing his edits. But it works for the gameplay experience. He knows basketball. You can tell how he breaks down his videos on YouTube. He also updates the playbooks. The best sliders to go with his set is his own slider set. He not only did rating edits and tendencies, but he did sig shots, equipment, and appearance too. He has Melo with the braids. He has Claxton with black dreads. Idk how he accomplished that. But yeah his roster sliders provide a more uptempo style of play. It’s a lot like todays nba. A lot of 3s. The cpu will shoot up to 30-40 3s.

                These are my guide on how to get the best slider experience on each roster.


                Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                Great information for us who want real simulation gameplay.
                Can you also suggest a simulation set for classic rosters and scenarios for each decade.For example 80's era had completely different style of play than the 2010's.

                Comment

                • Your Back Door Man
                  Rookie
                  • Nov 2021
                  • 39

                  #9
                  Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                  youdarealmvp.jpg

                  Comment

                  • atlwarya
                    Rookie
                    • Jun 2005
                    • 336

                    #10
                    Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                    Originally posted by COMMISSIONERHBK9
                    Great write up. Question which rosters do you use for your gameplay and if u do use atd do you use real fg or do u use shot timing

                    The default set has an issue where the cpu does not attempt enough 3s.
                    I definitely use ATD for PS5 with Schnaidt ATD slider set. It’s the only way to get least 30-40 3s a game with accurate stats. They spent a lot of time on the tendencies. The only thing is you have to update the signings, trades, and lineups yourself. Games end in between the 100s and 120s mostly. I also use real fg % because that’s what schnaidt recommended otherwise it’ll be too easy.

                    I spend a great amount of time on PS4 too using Real2Kinsider rosters too. His are the most up to date. The AI is a little better on this version but it has the same issues as it’s newer generation version. There aren’t enough 3 point attempts but the stats are accurate for each player. POPBOYS sliders worked but the patch messed it up, so I went back to default HOF at the moment. I wish there were more slider makers on this version too because current gen has more to offer on gameplay out the box than next gen. I use shot timing on this version. I wouldn’t recommend any sliders on PS4 for now but if you really want to choose, go with Popboys or Shadymikes.


                    Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                    Last edited by atlwarya; 01-15-2022, 07:03 PM.

                    Comment

                    • atlwarya
                      Rookie
                      • Jun 2005
                      • 336

                      #11
                      Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                      Originally posted by Damis
                      Great information for us who want real simulation gameplay.

                      Can you also suggest a simulation set for classic rosters and scenarios for each decade.For example 80's era had completely different style of play than the 2010's.


                      That’s a great question I don’t know at the moment but I can look into it. The default SS/HOF slider set is close to the 80s, 90s era style of basketball. There are not many 3s, it is very physical. It used to be this guy named MJWizards who made great old school rosters but I don’t know if he’s still active. Nogster made a great super league roster with players from all eras in 2k21 but idk if he is planning to do it this season. He has not even updated his 2k22 roster for over a month now.


                      Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

                      Comment

                      • Damis
                        Rookie
                        • Jan 2022
                        • 11

                        #12
                        Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                        Originally posted by atlwarya
                        That’s a great question I don’t know at the moment but I can look into it. The default SS/HOF slider set is close to the 80s, 90s era style of basketball. There are not many 3s, it is very physical. It used to be this guy named MJWizards who made great old school rosters but I don’t know if he’s still active. Nogster made a great super league roster with players from all eras in 2k21 but idk if he is planning to do it this season. He has not even updated his 2k22 roster for over a month now.


                        Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

                        Thank you very much for the reply.I am looking forward for your suggestions about the simulation of retro gameplay.

                        Comment

                        • atlwarya
                          Rookie
                          • Jun 2005
                          • 336

                          #13
                          Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                          Originally posted by Damis
                          Thank you very much for the reply.I am looking forward for your suggestions about the simulation of retro gameplay.


                          https://youtu.be/QwEvgZ1A2_I perfect timing! Here’s MJWizard’s YT channel. He’s actually doing a retro roster.


                          Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

                          Comment

                          • atlwarya
                            Rookie
                            • Jun 2005
                            • 336

                            #14
                            Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                            The patch changed the defensive physics so if you use the Default Roster or Real2Kinsider Rosters with default sliders or POPBOY sliders on PS4 and PS5, you need to to change the defensive assist to 50 in controller settings otherwise the gameplay will be weird. I believe 2k changed the movement physics. Next Gen is already set at 50 but current gen is at 0. You’ll have to go in and change it to 50. This will help the cpu defense on drives. This doesn’t apply to you if you’re using any other sliders.


                            Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

                            Comment

                            • COMMISSIONERHBK9
                              MVP
                              • Dec 2003
                              • 4564

                              #15
                              Re: Guide for what Rosters work for which Sliders PS4 / PS5

                              I have those strength to 100 cuz i thought i will help defend better isn’t that correct?



                              Originally posted by atlwarya
                              The patch changed the defensive physics so if you use the Default Roster or Real2Kinsider Rosters with default sliders or POPBOY sliders on PS4 and PS5, you need to to change the defensive assist to 50 in controller settings otherwise the gameplay will be weird. I believe 2k changed the movement physics. Next Gen is already set at 50 but current gen is at 0. You’ll have to go in and change it to 50. This will help the cpu defense on drives. This doesn’t apply to you if you’re using any other sliders.


                              Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
                              Check out my YouTube page

                              https://www.youtube.com/@mr_too_soon

                              https://twitter.com/Mr_too_soon

                              Comment

                              Working...