Top 10 QBs?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by Shakedowncapo

Ok, let me make the liste everyone can agree on. T. Brady P. Manning M. Bulger D. Brees C. Palmer B. Roethlisberger T. Romo M. Hasselbeck B. Farve K. Warner

Good list.

[tdawg3782]

Quote: Originally Posted by P2K

Everyone's in love with Eli now. Blah. He's still a mediocre QB, IMO.

Thank you. I agree 100%. Every single analyst loves Eli right now. Give me a break. He plays a couple decent games and now he's a superstar. How bout the fact the Giants defense has been off the charts. Or Plaxico has been a force. Plus B. Jacobs is giving them a solid running game. God. Sorry, strayed off topic.

I think McNabb should be in there. I could do with out Kurt Warner. I also think Big Ben is a little overrated. He's boarderline Top 10. imo

[Brandon13]

Brady
P. Manning
Favre
Brees
Romo
Roethlisberger
Palmer
Garrard
McNabb
Hasselbeck

Eli's overrated right now.

[ZB9]

Quote: Originally Posted by Shakedowncapo

Ok, let me make the liste everyone can agree on. T. Brady P. Manning M. Bulger D. Brees C. Palmer B. Roethlisberger T. Romo M. Hasselbeck B. Farve K. Warner

looks good, except for Bulger imo

Bulger is not ahead of Eli imo

[Brandon13]

Quote: Originally Posted by tdawg3782

Agreed. The times i've seen him play he has been borderline grabage. If we were doing a Top 10 potential QB list them maybe.

Borderline garbage is too strong. He was 12th in passer rating this year.

[Shakedowncapo]

Quote: Originally Posted by ZB9

looks good, except for Bulger imo Bulger is not ahead of Eli imo

From a pure passer standpoint, Bulger is a lot better than Eli. We've all seen what Marc is capable of when he has a healthy o-line the whole season. Can't knock the dude for having to work with 3rd and 4th stringers this year.

[ZB9]

Quote: Originally Posted by Shakedowncapo

From a pure passer standpoint, Bulger is a lot better than Eli. We've all seen what Marc is capable of when he has a healthy o-line the whole season. Can't knock the dude for having to work with 3rd and 4th stringers this year.

Would you take Bulger over Eli? Theres no way i would. I wouldnt take Bulger over Rivers or Garrard either. Bulger is not top 10 imo.

[Shakedowncapo]

Quote: Originally Posted by ZB9

Would you take Bulger over Eli? Theres no way i would. I wouldnt take Bulger over Rivers or Garrard either. Bulger is not top 10 imo.

Forgetting this playoff tear, would you really take Eli over Marc after what both have accomplished? I just have a hard time believing you would.

I just believe he's an elite QB when having a team at full strength.

As for Rivers and Garrard, I need to see just one more year from them. You think they will ever be straight up "passers"? I'm thinking more like game managers at this point(which both have done extremely well). Both players team lack the go-to WR(i didnt forget Gates ) and running the ball has been the key to their success.