Who is the most overrated Player in the NFL?

[Sting]

Shaun Rogers

I feel terrible for saying this...

I think Julius Peppers is overrated and he's my favorite player on earth. By the way take this as a note that I'm realistic in everything I say on this forum.

I wish he played harder. I think he is the best athlete in the NFL and could dominate but mentally I'm not sure he gives it his all. Yes this is the question about a lot of great athletes but damn I really want him to dominate!

He gets stood up on some plays and just gives up...I don't know what was wrong with him last year but he should not be dominated like he was. I really hope he steps up this year and gets back to 10+ sacks.

[gta95]

Quote: Originally Posted by Psyblast

1. No you couldn't. 2. Jabar Gaffney? Seriously? What has he done in the NFL to justify being covered by a #2 CB over Welker? Welker might be overrated in the sense that he's not the elite receiver his 2007 statistics tell, but it's not because he's got Jabar Gaffney next to him. All you have to do is watch him play and you can see he's a damn good player, and doesn't deserve to be at the top of an all-overrated list like Reggie Bush. ESPN doesn't fawn over Welker like a lot of other players.

1. Wes Welker was a God on ESPN by week 12.

2. Wes Welker continuously faced the number 3 and 4 CB each week. What happenned when he faced the good CBs in Miami?

[RAZRr1275]

Quote: Originally Posted by stewaat

I feel terrible for saying this... I think Julius Peppers is overrated and he's my favorite player on earth. By the way take this as a note that I'm realistic in everything I say on this forum. I wish he played harder. I think he is the best athlete in the NFL and could dominate but mentally I'm not sure he gives it his all. Yes this is the question about a lot of great athletes but damn I really want him to dominate! He gets stood up on some plays and just gives up...I don't know what was wrong with him last year but he should not be dominated like he was. I really hope he steps up this year and gets back to 10+ sacks.

The Rusheed Wallace of the NFL.

[jmood88]

[ZB9]Reggie Bush[/ZB9]

[55]

Reggie Bust

[CM Hooe]

Even though I'm a Cowboys' fan I'm gonna have to say Marion Barber, at least until he proves himself as a top-flight running back this season.

He's a good player, and I really like the way he plays, but the contract he was given before proving himself in a starting role was a bit absurd, IMO. I'm still baffled as to how he made the Pro Bowl squad, to be honest.

[Jistic]

Champ Bailey.