How good is Anquan Boldin?

[DocHolliday]

Id take boldin over in Chi town baby. Hes pretty damn solid and hes a big body.

[brad]

Quote: Originally Posted by wwharton

I'd love to hear them. You don't seem to know much about Boldin (hence, the thread you created) but you can name players you're positive are better?

If you looked at the reply i quoted you'd see I was talking about Berrian in that particular post and not Boldin.

As for Boldin, I know a bit not a whole lot I don't really follow that NFC west or the cards. I know hes a good wideout in my head i put him at between 10-12

In no particular order the wideouts i put ahead of him
1. Moss
2. Owens
3. Burress
4. Smith
5. Fitz
6. Chad
7. Wayne
8. Holt

This is where it gets tricky Boldin, Moss, Calvin Johnson, Roy Williams, Harrison, Ward. All seem to have arguments to be next.

[AlexBrady]

Quote: Originally Posted by brad

If you looked at the reply i quoted you'd see I was talking about Berrian in that particular post and not Boldin. As for Boldin, I know a bit not a whole lot I don't really follow that NFC west or the cards. I know hes a good wideout in my head i put him at between 10-12 In no particular order the wideouts i put ahead of him 1. Moss 2. Owens 3. Burress 4. Smith 5. Fitz 6. Chad 7. Wayne 8. Holt This is where it gets tricky Boldin, Moss, Calvin Johnson, Roy Williams, Harrison, Ward. All seem to have arguments to be next.

I like that list but i think reggie wayne is way better than you think he is. also, i don't think burress is all that great.

1. randy moss
2. terrell owens
3. steve smith
4. reggie wayne
5. larry fitzgerald
6. torry holt
7. chad johnson
8. roy williams

[Perceptor]

Quote: Originally Posted by AlexBrady

I like that list but i think reggie wayne is way better than you think he is. also, i don't think burress is all that great. 1. randy moss 2. terrell owens 3. steve smith 4. reggie wayne 5. larry fitzgerald 6. torry holt 7. chad johnson 8. roy williams

It wasn't in any particular order....just a random listing of players better than Anquan.

I think Boldin is a fringe top 10 receiver overall and I agree that he needs to stop whining about the contract and honoring his current one.

[Brandon13]

Quote: Originally Posted by brad

If you looked at the reply i quoted you'd see I was talking about Berrian in that particular post and not Boldin. As for Boldin, I know a bit not a whole lot I don't really follow that NFC west or the cards. I know hes a good wideout in my head i put him at between 10-12 In no particular order the wideouts i put ahead of him 1. Moss 2. Owens 3. Burress 4. Smith 5. Fitz 6. Chad 7. Wayne 8. Holt This is where it gets tricky Boldin, Moss, Calvin Johnson, Roy Williams, Harrison, Ward. All seem to have arguments to be next.

Erm... Marques Colston should get a mention as well.

[skydog71]

Quote: Originally Posted by Brandon13

Erm... Marques Colston should get a mention as well.

I'd give a mention to Andre Johnson and Braylon Edwards too.

[brad]

Quote: Originally Posted by skydog71

I'd give a mention to Andre Johnson and Braylon Edwards too.

I knew i forgot someone....

Edwards is def better the boldin imo and johnson is equal if not close. I don't know about colston, he needs to show us all one more year imo

So that would leave Boldin, somewhere between 10-15

[Brandon13]

Quote: Originally Posted by brad

I knew i forgot someone.... Edwards is def better the boldin imo and johnson is equal if not close. I don't know about colston, he needs to show us all one more year imo So that would leave Boldin, somewhere between 10-15

If that's the case against Colston then Calvin Johnson certainly shouldn't be listed.