Is Kurt Warner a HOF QB?

[The Chef]

Quote: Originally Posted by totalownership

Are you guys serious? I guess none of you are old enough to remember "The greatest show on turf". Kurt had HOF written on him WELL before he got to the Cardinals.

I remember the greatest show on turf but I still dont think a few years in that offense suddenly means he is hall of fame worthy. Like I said, Im assuming Im by myself on this, especially considering he is the top story in sports right now and has everyones sentimental pick for the hall because of what he did this season and in the playoffs thus far.

Quote: Originally Posted by speedkills

Is Dan Fouts in the HOF? If so, then yes because Warner is more accomplished.

Thats assuming I think Fouts deserved to be in the hall and besides his 40,000+ yards passing, he had a terrible TD-INT split (254-242) so Im not a huge believer in Fouts either. Now if this is a question as to whether we think he will get in then I dont doubt it based on who else is in there currently, but I assumed this was a question as to whether or not we, the fans, thought he deserved to be in the hall or not.

[JayBee74]

• Only QB to throw for 300+ yards in his first 3 NFL starts.
• His 1999-2001 Rams are the only NFL team to score 500 points in three consecutive seasons.
• The forgotten years of 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, and 2006 will hurt Warner for HOF consideration. Last year he got back respectability with 27 TDs and 17 Ints, and this year is probably his greatest since winning the SB for the '99 season.

Tough call, but a trip to the Super Bowl this year might get him in.

[TimmeH]

I dunno. He's had a few amazing years. But he's only been his team's primary starting quarterback for seven of his eleven seasons, and two of those seven he got benched towards the end of the season due to poor performance in favor of a rookie quarterback. When you break his career down, he's had three awesome seasons, two good seasons, two so-so seasons, and five seasons as a backup.

He's a good quarterback, but he's been blessed with some amazing offenses around him(Holt/Bruce/Faulk & Boldin/Fitzgerald/Breaston). I'd say no Hall just yet.

[MaddenMan]

He deserves it as much as Terrell Davis does. So yeah but not on first ballot.

[Brian Gee]

Quote: Originally Posted by MaddenMan

He deserves it as much as Terrell Davis does. So yeah but not on first ballot.

That's the best comparison I've ever heard. You hit the nail on the head.

[SportsTop]

Quote: Originally Posted by MaddenMan

He deserves it as much as Terrell Davis does. So yeah but not on first ballot.

We've already had the Kurt Warner HOF discussion at length in this thread.

[Cebby]

Quote: Originally Posted by JayBee74

Tough call, but a trip to the Super Bowl this year might get him in.

A trip to the Super Bowl this year and Warner is the lock of locks.

[Candyman5]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Chef

I remember the greatest show on turf but I still dont think a few years in that offense suddenly means he is hall of fame worthy. Like I said, Im assuming Im by myself on this, especially considering he is the top story in sports right now and has everyones sentimental pick for the hall because of what he did this season and in the playoffs thus far. Thats assuming I think Fouts deserved to be in the hall and besides his 40,000+ yards passing, he had a terrible TD-INT split (254-242) so Im not a huge believer in Fouts either. Now if this is a question as to whether we think he will get in then I dont doubt it based on who else is in there currently, but I assumed this was a question as to whether or not we, the fans, thought he deserved to be in the hall or not.

Sounds like Bret Farve.....