Let's get real here, the only negativity that having an Elway would be is winning playoff games and getting to the SB.
Cutler had an incredible offense in Denver and couldn't even make the friggin playoffs, let alone win a playoff game.
I seriously doubt that his chances have improved going to Chicage but I don't wish him bad or anything.
Plummer
Cuter
Orton
It's that simple - Plummer got them to the AFC Championship game vs the Steelers at home.
Cutler get's off to a hot start in the season and in games then he implodes ala Brian Greise.
So the "Bronco Hate" you speak of isn't completely unwarranted, sure Elway plays a part but our most recent memory is of Greise, and Plummer and Cutler might have had better stats than Plummer but he didn't win which is why stats are overrated - just ask Dan Marino.