Was Tony Dungy Overrated?

[Chip Douglass]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

If you think Manning dont need his O.C. check his interview when he thought that Tom Moore was going retire. Im sure Manning has a great deal of input in the playcalling but to say a QB would be successful in todays game without an O.C. is crazy.

Did I say that Manning didn't need an OC?

Everything that I said in that post is quoted almost verbatim from his OC.

[BAMJ6]

I love TC, and nobody's questioning Tom Coughlin's overratedness but it'll be Dungy? They both have the same number of Super Bowl titles and appearances and Dungy has one more Conference title game appearance than TC does

Is it because Dungy was a conservative coach or a hardass or is it because of you know what

[CW McGraw]

Quote: Originally Posted by BAMJ6

I love TC, and nobody's questioning Tom Coughlin's overratedness but it'll be Dungy? They both have the same number of Super Bowl titles and appearances and Dungy has one more Conference title game appearance than TC does Is it because Dungy was a conservative coach or a hardass or is it because of you know what

Tom Coughlin will never sniff the Hall of Fame. Tony Dungy will be in Canton sooner rather than later.

[Vince]

Quote: Originally Posted by CW McGraw

Dungy really didn't do much in Indianapolis. Their problems prior to Dungy were on defense. Nearly a decade later, their defense has still routinely lost them winnable playoff games. If Dungy were the supposed defensive genius he has been billed to be, the Colts would have been a dynasty. Great QB+Innovate Defensive Minded Coach should=multiple championships. Dungy walked into an ideal situation and ultimately was a disappointment. At the end of the day, was Dungy really just a better version of Brian Billick?

Horrible argument because the Colts spend more on the offensive side of the balll.

They developped good Defensive players.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Vince

Horrible argument because the Colts spend more on the offensive side of the balll. They developped good Defensive players.

Yeah that seems more like of a Peyton Manning problem. It amazes me how some people give Manning all the credit for the regular season success and none of the blame for their post season failures.

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Yeah that seems more like of a Peyton Manning problem. It amazes me how some people give Manning all the credit for the regular season success and none of the blame for their post season failures.

I don't know how you came to that conclusion. People blast Manning all the time for the Colts' Playoff woes(sometimes fairly, sometimes unfairly too).

Either way, let's not go down that path and turn this thread into something it shouldn't be.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

I don't know how you came to that conclusion. People blast Manning all the time for the Colts' Playoff woes(sometimes fairly, sometimes unfairly too). Either way, let's not go down that path and turn this thread into something it shouldn't be.

I clearly said some people. Meaning not all.

[BAMJ6]

Quote: Originally Posted by CW McGraw

Tom Coughlin will never sniff the Hall of Fame. Tony Dungy will be in Canton sooner rather than later.

I never said he would. I'm just saying no ones questioning if he's overrated or not Dungy has the better coaching career than him right now

Don't get me wrong though I love Coughlin because he coached my favorite NFL team the Giants to a championship in my fanhood and i always will