Chris Johnson: Biggest MVP Heist In History?

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by CodeBlueDude

this is like the 4th time he's won MVP it seems like.

It seems like it because it is his 4th.

Quote:

Chris Johnson had a great season , and in my opinion had a better than Manning.

Statistically, yes, and that's why he won OPOY.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Olson-for-Heisman

A. Bad defense B. Ran into the dynasty of the 2000s 3 times. Are we seriously questioning the value of Peyton Manning to the Colts?

Im not saying he isnt valuable but this idea that the QB position always have to be the most valuable to be successful is BS. Because if a great QB trumps everything Manning's post-season record should be better.

So if were going use CJ's teams record to lessen his value. Then you have to use Manning's post season record to lessen his value. Fair is fair!

[Scottdau]

I don't know if there is anyone as valuable to their team than CJ, but that doesn't matter. This is MVP of league. If CJ team won their division or they at least made the playoffs with a good record. Then he probably would have won this award.

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Im not saying he isnt valuable but this idea that the QB position always have to be the most valuable to be successful is BS. Because if a great QB trumps everything Manning's post-season record should be better. So if were going use CJ's teams record to lessen his value. Then you have to use Manning's post season record to lessen his value. Fair is fair!

If this is how you feel then why were you arguing for Brees to win the MVP?

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

If this is how you feel then why were you arguing for Brees to win the MVP?

In that poll I voted for CJ. And I also said so in my post. Go back and check.

[HungryBologna]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Im not saying he isnt valuable but this idea that the QB position always have to be the most valuable to be successful is BS. Because if a great QB trumps everything Manning's post-season record should be better. So if were going use CJ's teams record to lessen his value. Then you have to use Manning's post season record to lessen his value. Fair is fair!

As far as a I know the MVP is a regular season award for that particular season.

[jnofx]

I've compiled a list of MVP's whose team started off 0-6 and failed to make the playoffs. Here goes:

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.


Feel free to make any corrections.

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

In that poll I voted for CJ. And I also said so in my post. Go back and check.

You were pretty two faced in that thread. You argued for Brees winning it over Manning. Then said you voted for CJ. Then argued more about Brees. Then posted this when Manning officially won it..

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Manning was a worthy choice ,but I would have rather had Brees win though.

Either way it doesn't matter, that wasn't even my point. My point is that you're now downplaying Manning's MVP because of his Post Season record, yet just a week ago you argued for Brees(who has a lower winning % in the Playoffs than Peyton).