So, why was Vince Young a 1st round prospect, and Tebow is a 4th-5th?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by OKAY OKAY

VY: No one contested him as being a starting, and potentially STAR, NFL QB. .

Where are you getting this? Plenty of people questioned whether Young had the passing skills to become a NFL starting QB.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by ex carrabba fan

This guy seems wound up and/or upset

Over a topic that really doesn't mean anything. Who cares what TV draft analysts not named Mike Mayock have to say anyway?

[OKAY OKAY]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

I am not sure where you are getting VY doesn't have good arm strength. While he doesn't have elite arm strength, he's got a plus arm that from a velocity and arm strength standpoint can make all the throws. The questions as to Young's NFL passing ability are more decision making and accuracy than arm strength. I don't think anyone in the league worries he lacks the arm strength to make it as an NFL QB.

I'm probably over emphasizing his arm strength because I'm repeating myself, but I'm not analyzing VY's arm as not being able to make the NFL throws. I'm just talking about him at the professional level...

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by ex carrabba fan

This guy seems wound up and/or upset

Yeah. I think his question is fair, but he's going a little overboard with it.

[OKAY OKAY]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Where are you getting this? Plenty of people questioned whether Young had the passing skills to become a NFL starting QB.

lol Young was agreed to be a Top 10 pick... and the 2nd best QB coming out of a draft where the QB class was supposed to be the "future of the NFL."

[OKAY OKAY]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Over a topic that really doesn't mean anything. Who cares what TV draft analysts not named Mike Mayock have to say anyway?

It doesn't matter - all I'm doing is asking a simple question. Obviously, I should have asked it in the way I edited it, probably would have been better.

But, no it doesn't matter what those TV analysts have to say at the end of the day.

[OKAY OKAY]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

Yeah. I think his question is fair, but he's going a little overboard with it.

lol probably because I'm responding to everyone, but I'm only really responding to people who are deviating from the real question.

[Bellsprout]

Is there a reason you haven't addressed the Vick factor yet? Is it because it makes sense and therefore kills your topic?