Micheal Vick or Eli Manning Who's a better overall #1?

[kingkilla56]

easy eli all day. Ill take eli manning over his draft mates Phillip Rivers and Big Ben every time. Eli just has a thing about him that you have to see to believe. He'll be having the worst game of his life or be in the game winning drive of the superbowl and you wouldn't know the difference in his expression. Calm cool and collected, exactly what New York team sports leader need cough cough sanchez lol.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by kingkilla56

easy eli all day. Ill take eli manning over his draft mates Phillip Rivers and Big Ben every time. Eli just has a thing about him that you have to see to believe. He'll be having the worst game of his life or be in the game winning drive of the superbowl and you wouldn't know the difference in his expression. Calm cool and collected, exactly what New York team sports leader need cough cough sanchez lol.

LMAO!!!!

[Shawnj86]

I will take Eli
But i would take the '02 and '04(playoff)-'06 Vick tho

[King Gro23]

Does anyone think that had Vick not gone to prison he could of developed even more into a 3,000 yd passer. Not consistent 3,000 yd but Maybe one year out of 2006-2009. I remember watching his last year with Falcons and commentators would comment on how even though his stats arent showing it he was improving as a QB. He got sacked an awful lot, some tied to scrambling, but not all of it. WHo were his receivers and T.J. Duckett , and Warrick Dunn running the ball for him. He also got to a NFC Championship game. 1,000 Yd rusher. With a defense Ranked I believe in the low 20's. Granted he just came back last year shook off the rust. Behing kevin Kolb. Whats wrong with him now. He is a changed man, much more polite and well mannered. His Work ethic is improved. But never was below suspect. I think it is a tough Comparison because Eli Manning has his share of achievements

[themessenger]

Manning

[themessenger]

with Vick a close 2nd

[JayBee74]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Personally I think Vick is the better overall QB. And the media invest to much stock in superbowl rings at the QB position.

Does this poll question have any merit? Vick routinely posts QB ratings in the 60s and 70s, completion percentages in the mid 50%, and has thrown for 20 TDs only once. A Dan Marino without a SuperBowl he IS NOT!

Keep polishing your Michael Vick Fan Club button if it makes you feel better.

[Sheamazin]

Superbowl MVP > Dog Killer