Micheal Vick or Eli Manning Who's a better overall #1?

[JerseySuave4]

Not even close, its Eli

I'm not an Eli fan but he's got a ring already and has been a model citizen for his team.

I think Vick is the better talent, Eli has had the better career so far.

[jeremym480]

Quote: Originally Posted by MrOctober430

Michael Vick has a better dog fighting career, but as a football player, Eli.

[Jukeman]

Trent Dilfer won a SB...

[ProfessaPackMan]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dislimb

How is this even a debate?

Quote: Originally Posted by thelwig14

These are the kind of threads that need to be closed upon creation. Vince Young or Brett Favre? Matt Ryan or Tom Brady? Who comes up with these...

QFT

[ryan36]

I don't care what team you pick. Pick ANY team. They win more games with Eli. Therefore Eli= better.

I don't know anyone in ANY context who could think that Mike Vick would win more games with ANY GIVEN TEAM, than Eli.

Proof: If a GM came up to you and said , "Hey for a 3rd or 4th round pick you can have a QB better than Eli Manning," you'd take it. Vick is still an Eagle.

[WazzuRC]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jukeman

Trent Dilfer won a SB...

Trent Dilfer also completed 60% of his passes and played behind one of the greatest defenses of all-time.

[TheWatcher]

We're not comparing Eli Manning to Trent Dilfer are we? Besides the fact that they both won Super Bowls, they have nothing in common and Eli is definitely the better QB of the two.

[Jukeman]

Quote: Originally Posted by WazzuRC

Trent Dilfer also completed 60% of his passes and played behind one of the greatest defenses of all-time.

my point proven

55% 60%

Stats means nothing