Micheal Vick or Eli Manning Who's a better overall #1?

[Bears_16_and_0]

rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl cmon

[EWRMETS]

Quote: Originally Posted by SoxFan01605

I don't know that anyone predicted he'd win a title earlier in his career, but many analysts said they thought Eli could be even better than Peyton and at least as good. Now, this was all early on during the hype-train that was his draft, so take that for what it's worth.

I remember hearing Eli is more athletic than Peyton (which he is), but never heard that he would be better. Of course Eli is a better #1 pick than Vick...he already has won a ring and hasn't embarassed his franchise.

[Aggies7]

I personally think this is not even close. By far its Eli Manning. He is still a franchise QB for the Giants.

[beelo]

ELI, yes he cant run around the field like Vick could/can, but Manning knows how to lead a team. ELI could still use some poloshing, but he has proven he can lead a team

[TecmoZack]

Quote: Originally Posted by SoxFan01605

I don't know that anyone predicted he'd win a title earlier in his career, but many analysts said they thought Eli could be even better than Peyton and at least as good. Now, this was all early on during the hype-train that was his draft, so take that for what it's worth.

It was Archie Manning who said when it is over said and done with Eli will have a better career...I believe he is referring to Super Bowl wins and not passing records...

Just depends on how you rate greatness...Who is better Marino or Montana...you can argue either way...

[edaddy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dawkinseffect

I can't believe there is even a thread/poll for this. Vick was out of football for 2 seasons and in jail. Eli won a Superbowl. I think we all know who had a better career at the moment.

Bingo..There is no comparison at this point Eli has had a much more stellar consistent career complete with a SuperBowl victory and MVP to boot...I dont get it..this isn't even poll worthy..lol

[49er14]

I'd probally go with Eli, over Vick. He won a SB, and got more experiance.

[PantherBeast_OS]

LOL not even close. Vick was a decent QB but not good. He scramble most the time. His accuracy was decent at best and never came close to a SB won. Eli in his second are third year won himself a SB ring with the Giant and he is a muck better thrower then vick will ever be. Not even close lol.