Poll: Who is the better WR?

[bkrich83]

When CJ starts performing like Fitz on a consistent basis, we can have this conversation. At this point, it's not even close.

[PantherBeast_OS]

To be very honest it is hard to tell. Both WRs are good. It's very hard to tell at this point to be quite honest. So I would say both are good to be plain straight up about it.

[PGaither84]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

When CJ starts performing like Fitz on a consistent basis, we can have this conversation. At this point, it's not even close.

This.

A great example is Randy Moss. Randy makes teams better. I really like Tim Brown and Chris Carter and a number of other WRs in history but after Jerry Rice, Randy Moss has got to be in contention for the #2 all time slot.

Regarding CJ vs Fitz, it comes down to what they have done and how they do it. I saw CJ play in college and he was a beast, he is a beast in the NFL, however, don't forget what Fitz did in the playoffs just two years ago. It would have been interesting to see what CJ could have done if he wasn't drafted by Detroit [just like Barry Sanders.] I really hope CJ doesn't lock himself up his whole career there. The Lions haven't been good since about 1957 and they won't be for a long time when you look at how they run their team year in and year out.

[Tyrant8RDFL]

Very tough call, but at this time its Friz's , but when both careers are over it may be Calvin.

[Mr360BeasTx]

Quote: Originally Posted by PGaither84

This. A great example is Randy Moss. Randy makes teams better. I really like Tim Brown and Chris Carter and a number of other WRs in history but after Jerry Rice, Randy Moss has got to be in contention for the #2 all time slot. Regarding CJ vs Fitz, it comes down to what they have done and how they do it. I saw CJ play in college and he was a beast, he is a beast in the NFL, however, don't forget what Fitz did in the playoffs just two years ago. It would have been interesting to see what CJ could have done if he wasn't drafted by Detroit [just like Barry Sanders.] I really hope CJ doesn't lock himself up his whole career there. The Lions haven't been good since about 1957 and they won't be for a long time when you look at how they run their team year in and year out.

Dont say that man ..your scary me if he leaves i would be torn

[Buckeyes_Doc]

Fitz by a long shot. The stats do not lie. This isn't debatable at this point in time, IMO.

[ProfessaPackMan]

Fitz.

[Megatron2k7]

They are both damn good WR's.

I think C.J. has a few physical attributes that are better, but Fitz currently has the better skill set. Simple as that.

In fact... I would wager that Fitz may have the best skill set of all the currently playing WR's. It's what makes him as good as he is. It's definitely not his speed or quickness that makes him one of the best. I'm not saying he's super slow or anything, what I mean is that he is a true master of his craft even though physically there are many that are more blessed, but will never reach his level of polish.