Brady, P.Manning or Roethlisberger?

[Andrews85]

Quote: Originally Posted by Beantown

They would also get rid of the ball a lot quicker than Big Ben does.

Well when the Jets played the Colts and Pats they got pressure and made both QB's look average. With an even worse o-line it would only be magnified.

[Wazzup36]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

There are 5 QB's I'd take before Big Ben. Manning Brady Brees Rivers Rodgers

Exactly my thinking. I might have to throw in Matt Ryan, though most likely not, maybe in a year.

[Palo20]

Quote: Originally Posted by Andrews85

Well when the Jets played the Colts and Pats they got pressure and made both QB's look average. With an even worse o-line it would only be magnified.

And you could easily argue that Brady and Manning STILL played better than Big Ben against the Jets. Big Ben definitely made plays when he needed to, and he moved the chains with his legs, but he still made some terrible throws which didn't come back to bite him.

[tripwire]

Quote: Originally Posted by biglen

I don't think it matters that they haven't had a top 10 rusher since '07. When they NEED to run the ball, they do it very well and it takes pressure off of Ben.

Their rushing game is a myth, ask any Steeler fan that sits and actually watches every game. They haven't had a decent run game or Oline to support Ben in years. Don't know where you get that info or impression.

[Andrews85]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

And you could easily argue that Brady and Manning STILL played better than Big Ben against the Jets. He definitely made plays when he needed to, and he moved the chains with his legs, but he still made some terrible throws which didn't come back to bite him.

He had 2 INT's and the first one wasn't his fault. There were countless times that he moved the chain just on his athletic ability alone. The 1st conversion at the end of the game is a perfect example.

[TexasBorn1]

Quote: Originally Posted by tripwire

Their rushing game is a myth, ask any Steeler fan that sits and actually watches every game. They haven't had a decent run game or Oline to support Ben in years. Don't know where you get that info or impression.

Yeah okay. Mendanhall didn't have over a hundred yards rushing in the first half against the Jets

Nope, no support at all

[biglen]

Quote: Originally Posted by Andrews85

I've never really liked the sport of baseball. It probably has something to do with the Pirates being so terrible while I was growing up. I'm 25, 18 of those years the Pirates have had a losing season. I still go to a game or two a year, but I just don't follow the sport. I love people who think if you but Brady or Manning behind the Steelers O-line that they would be just as good or better LOL. Both would get sacked 5-10 times a game.

I disagree. Manning and Brady both get rid of the ball quick and Ben tends to hold onto the ball just a bit too long causing him to get sacked.

[gr18]

Peyton had a 108.7 qb rating against the Jets,btw.It was the special teams that blew the game.