2011 MVP VOTE !!!

[Chrisksaint]

Saints offensive line is probably better based on talent, 2 all pro Guards and a pretty decent LT in Jermon Bushrod.

In actual performance? Idk I don't watch the Packers all the time, I know the Saints allow a lot of pressure off the edge. Brees probably has some of the best pocket awareness i've seen from a QB and the latest example was avoiding a few sacks from Jared Allen

[ABR173rd]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

So, if the Packers win out, Rodgers doesn't deserve it?

I think it will then depend on numbers, I'm not saying stats are the be all end all but the A.P. is doing the voting and if/when Brees breaks the passing record it will have a big impact on voting. To be honest outside of the Packers only having one loss and Brees breaking the single season passing record you could justify either one.

[Rocky]

Quote: Originally Posted by cjonesfan921

It's a QB league. Rodgers. Honestly, all these QB stats are skewed so terribly. That's how the NFL wanted it. Marino's record will get broken, and he did it in a time where WR got mauled, now if you accidentally graze, it's a flag.

I agree which is why I really want to vote for DeMarcus Ware with Arian Foster and Patrick Willis coming in close for a second and third.

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by ABR173rd

I think it will then depend on numbers, I'm not saying stats are the be all end all but the A.P. is doing the voting and if/when Brees breaks the passing record it will have a big impact on voting. To be honest outside of the Packers only having one loss and Brees breaking the single season passing record you could justify either one.

They are having great seasons.

[mestevo]

Quote: Originally Posted by Evan_OS

This is what confuses me, how does Rodgers win the MVP but another offensive player wins player of the year? If Rodgers wins the MVP then he should be the player of the year on offense instead of awarding it to a lesser player.

Brees was/is better offensively. Rodgers has great numbers but has made it look effortless for many weeks and will be MVP both for his numbers (2nd only to Brees most likely after 2 more weeks) and how he's run the team. Pretty straightforward IMO.

Unless MJD or McCoy run for 700-800 yards the final 2 weeks and come close to 2k, I don't think they are in competition against whomever ends up with the passing yardage record for offensive POY.

[SteelersFreak]

If you're gonna use the backup argument, just give it to Peyton because the proof is in the 1-13 pudding with them.

[areobee401]

Can't argue against the season Aaron Rodgers is having. 4360 passing yards with 40 TD and only 6 INT's. If he doesn't play at such a high level with that defense behind him there is no way Green Bay only have 1 loss.

With that said I still voted for Tom Brady.

[rangerrick012]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

Matt Flynn hasn't even proved himself. One game against the Patriots? He could also be another Kolb.

Or Caleb Hanie.

To me it's Rodgers no question.