2011/12 Defensive Rookie of the Year

[Chrisksaint]

Aldon Smith has been good and all in pass rushing situations, but Von Miller has been pretty good at that as well as well as solid in all those other situations that I don't think Smith is on the field for.

[Scott812313]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chrisksaint

Aldon Smith has been good and all in pass rushing situations, but Von Miller has been pretty good at that as well as well as solid in all those other situations that I don't think Smith is on the field for.

Smith is a situational player because SF has the best LB core in the league. You better believe if Smith played for Denver, he'd start and play all 3 downs too.

[Jasong7777]

**Homer Alert**

Ryan Kerrigan needs to be added to the list.

TACK SOLO AST SACK FF INT TD
63 41 22 7.5 4 1 1

[Scott812313]

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-the-se...-Striking-gold

[Chrisksaint]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scott812313

Smith is a situational player because SF has the best LB core in the league. You better believe if Smith played for Denver, he'd start and play all 3 downs too.

K but he didn't soo that's why i'm going with Miller

[BMott418]

Why are Sheard and McCarthy not in the poll?

[goh]

Because it was pretty much between Smith and Miller anyway and I was only putting 5.

[rdnk]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scott812313

Smith is a situational player because SF has the best LB core in the league. You better believe if Smith played for Denver, he'd start and play all 3 downs too.

He'd play DE there and then he might start every down. Von Miller played every down against the run and had to drop into coverage. Although it's tougher to compare because Denver and San Fran run different defenses. As such, I voted Von Miller and I do agree with Ryan Kerrigan being added to the list. Washington is set for a longtime with him and Orakpo rushing the passer.