Week 15: Seattle Seahawks (11-2) @ New York Giants (5-8)

[Lieutenant Dan]

Quote: Originally Posted by kingkilla56

Theoretically yes, actually no.

Yeah okay...just saw that alarming stat of Eli and his franchise high 168 career interceptions. Yikes.

Your point is made King.

[buss one]

I'd rather have 2 SB mixed with bad years than being a playoff team every year but getting knocked out every time.

[kingkilla56]

Quote: Originally Posted by buss one

I'd rather have 2 SB mixed with bad years than being a playoff team every year but getting knocked out every time.

If you guarantee me random superbowls every couple years I'd take it too. Except you can't guarantee something like that.

[kingkilla56]

Eli Manning is the worst starting quarterback in the NFL.

[gr18]

I know you have to go by the current state of the team and I'm not sure if one specific position should get more blame than another.Eli wouldn't be held in a high regard if it weren't for the two playoff runs.In fact he would be considered highly inconsistent.You can't disregard what Eli ultimately did though.He gets a free pass for at least this year.Joe Flacco isn't doing much better and he did it once.

I'm not saying I'd be ready to commit to Eli for multiple years and would take a wait to evaluate next year approach.It's hard to believe how much he and his brother are perceived as polar opposites.There's no question how good and consistent Peyton is until it comes to postseason.I don't think those games were always assessed fairly either.

[SteelersFreak]

Quote: Originally Posted by kingkilla56

Eli Manning is the worst starting quarterback in the NFL.

Chad Henne is a starting quarterback in the NFL. Eli Manning is not worse than Chad Henne.

[Lieutenant Dan]

Great win getting the shutout, Seahawks!

Giants I hope Cruz will be okay. Good luck the rest of the way.

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by kingkilla56

Eli Manning is the worst starting quarterback in the NFL.

Probably Geno Smith but he's a rookie.