I didn't play 2002, but I had 2003 and 2004 and freakin' loved them. I liked them so much, I played at least one game per week for the whole year. 2005 is WAY off the mark in my opinion. A little defensive tweaking to allow the CPU defense to disguise their blitzes more would have been perfect for me. Instead, this total rehaul of the defense and passing game make the game no fun. If the CPU can't complete 50%+ consistently, it's not a good representation of college football. I put mine on Ebay yesterday. I sincerely hope next year's brings the elements of 2004 back that made it a good game.