I dunno man, I never play with any of the DB's until the ball is in the air. So yes, I go and make plays. But, if you play differently - you can't claim the "terrible human pass coverage that can't be fixed" card. Sure it can, switch to the DB and make the play yourself.
I mean yes, from all of my time testing these sliders, and especially my old NHL Hockey ones, I know that you can't please everyone. And I can understand that you guys like to play with a LB or a corner or whatever and only that player. But at that point, I've got to tell you to try to make your own sliders. The CPU is supposed to be challenging on All-Madden, and if you leave all the big decisions to YOUR CPU players, they are going to get outworked, I'm fairly sure of it.
I think instead of trying the control 1, leave 10 idea - you guys might want to try to switch players and make plays. Then you know if you screwed up, then it was your fault. Don't leave the CPU to make the plays for you, this game simply wasn't designed with that in mind, at least on All-Madden.
Obviously it may be different from how you normally would play the game, but would you rather have a more realistic statistical game where you switch control between your whole team, or a game where you play by yourself and everything is out of whack? I mean if you guys get it perfect on another difficulty level/slider set - then kudos to you. But I think you're looking up the wrong trees trying to do that with this years Madden, at least if you want any level of statistical realism.