For one thing all of the pitchs have not been changed that was a list that someone posted on another forum that they beleived needed to be changed. Out of all of the response's in this thread none of them have been from the roster creators so i dont see how anyone said there would be no roster editing. I, and numerous others have been helping to create a roster set as close to accurate as possible, be that importing missing players, editing attributes to make players as close to real life a possible, and getting players on the right teams. I use these rosters and i have yet to see anything abnormal. Maybe the rosters that you are talking about from last year were all messed up because 2004 was buggy as hell but still a great game. Rest assured badgun that there is no "Prince Fielder favrotism" going on here. Maybe you should check out these rosters if you already havent im sure you will be pleasantly surprised.