Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post - Where's the Challenges??? (Big Ten/ACC/Big 12)

outkast44 · 07-20-2005, 08:01 PM

What's the point really? With those college rules, the cpu ai would purposely make a bad call so that it (not you) can make the decision to challenge it. Once it is challenged, you'd probably be shown a couple replays of the play and then the call would or wouldn't be changed. But you'd just be sitting there watching! It might be cool the first couple of times, but afterwards... its probably something you'd turn off or skip through.

If those conferences ever made it like NFL rules where coaches make the call for the review... then I would like it to be part of the game. Otherwise, it would be pretty pointless in my opinion. The fact that it is a part of NFL strategy and requires user input is the only reason its even mildly interesting in Madden.

07-20-2005, 08:01 PM	#5
outkast44 Rookie OVR: 3 Join Date: Feb 2003	Re: Where's the Challenges??? (Big Ten/ACC/Big 12) What's the point really? With those college rules, the cpu ai would purposely make a bad call so that it (not you) can make the decision to challenge it. Once it is challenged, you'd probably be shown a couple replays of the play and then the call would or wouldn't be changed. But you'd just be sitting there watching! It might be cool the first couple of times, but afterwards... its probably something you'd turn off or skip through. If those conferences ever made it like NFL rules where coaches make the call for the review... then I would like it to be part of the game. Otherwise, it would be pretty pointless in my opinion. The fact that it is a part of NFL strategy and requires user input is the only reason its even mildly interesting in Madden.