I haven't played enough yet to tell if different kickers/punters move at different speeds - but the obvious thing was that the downward meter moves faster than the initial upward meter so those of you who are trained to have a "rythmn" to how you 3-click will have trouble - you have to be prepared to click the 3rd time faster than you have in the past.
I SUCKED for a long time last night playing! I basically felt like I had to click the 3rd time almost immediately after i clicked the 2nd time!
(All-pro level)