[Flawless]

I rented Madden the other day, and I will be sticking with NCAA.

NCAA is alot more responsive when controlling your players, Madden feels stiff to me. The ball looks so much better in the air in NCAA than Madden. I like NCAA's player models and animations better. The overall atmosphere and presentation in NCAA is better.

There is a few things I do like better in Madden though. Running up the middle is better, and little less ping pong-ish. The play fakes look much better. The defensive back AI is a little better, not as easy to complete deep passes. I like the QB vision/precision passing. I like all the audible options you have on offense and defense too. Other than that, I just find NCAA a more enjoyable game.