Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post

wwharton · 06-05-2008, 03:23 PM

Some constructive criticism...

Most madden/2k debates have a gray area created by the people that haven't really played the other game. Here you didn't really talk about Madden's features in a couple of areas besides to say it's about the same as the last version. This doesn't really say anything to anyone that hasn't played that version.

Also, as mentioned, the 2k5 franchise mode was far from perfect and I'm definitely a huge 2k5 fan. It was the biggest complaint by those that loved and hated the game. I also think Madden's mini camps deserves a bit more credit. 2k5's practice mode is a great place to learn the game but I really think it could've helped EVERYONE if it was more structured like the way EA does with Madden.

I'm defending the evil empire a bit, but I agree with your assessment.

06-05-2008, 03:23 PM	#12
wwharton ll Str OVR: 28 Join Date: Aug 2002 Posts: 26,978	Some constructive criticism... Most madden/2k debates have a gray area created by the people that haven't really played the other game. Here you didn't really talk about Madden's features in a couple of areas besides to say it's about the same as the last version. This doesn't really say anything to anyone that hasn't played that version. Also, as mentioned, the 2k5 franchise mode was far from perfect and I'm definitely a huge 2k5 fan. It was the biggest complaint by those that loved and hated the game. I also think Madden's mini camps deserves a bit more credit. 2k5's practice mode is a great place to learn the game but I really think it could've helped EVERYONE if it was more structured like the way EA does with Madden. I'm defending the evil empire a bit, but I agree with your assessment.