Alright buddy so which is it? You're basically saying all of us long time gamers suck and don't really know football, but then you say fine tuning gameplay would be a bonus. Why fine tune the gameplay when the problem is that we just all suck?
I'll never understand people who refuse to acknowledge the obvious. The defensive players are too slow on this game: FACT The difference between your defensive players, and the CPU defensive players is night & day.
The problem is this, although you come out in the end(assuming Madden is playable) you have given EA $120 altogether and only have 1 game to show for it.