Why Madden Will Be Better Than NCAA

[topzzz]

lol fistofridge

[SoxFan01605]

Re: Why Madden Will Be Better Than NCAA

Your opinion and I respect it. But for me NCAA is the King of football video games. The nature of the sport just translates better to a video game. Fast gameplay with short play clocks.

I know a lot of people who feel the same way as you. I just prefer NFL as I actually have a team I follow. If they would just reimpliment create-a-team and the 1AA schools, there wouldn't even be a discussion...lol

[StormJH1]

Madden may very well end up being better than NCAA, but this article gives pretty vague and generic reasons as to why that would be? Things like "more even teams" have been a factor since we got Bill Walsh CF in 1995, why pretend like they're suddenly going to become a huge factor now?

Also, I reject the "NCAA as beta test for Madden argument". While it might be the case that the dynasty problems with EA's online servers might have prompted them to make some changes to their servers b/c of NCAA, NCAA was released in mid-July...there simply isn't enough time for EA to monitor consumer feedback and then make changes to a final build within the span of a month. And if they tried to do that, they'd probably screw up more than they fixed.