There is no argument. Madden, right now, is EA Sports worst game.
1. NHL
2. NBA Live
3. Fifa
4. Tiger Woods
5. NCAA Football
6. Madden
(I actually have more funh with Live than NHL, but the consensus is pretty clear about NHL being EA Sports' best game. I just don't play Fifa enough to have a credible opinion on the game, so I leave it to others)
And when NCAA Basketball 09 comes out, Madden falls to #7. Their college basketball title is gonna surprise many people.