Why doubtful on Shields? He may not be a 90 in the game but he should be. He's very underrated. He's better than Felix Hernandez and yet he's always rated over 90.
2007: 215 IP, 202 Hits, 36 BB, 184 K's, 3.85 ERA, 1.11 WHIP
2008: 215 IP, 208 Hits, 40 BB, 160 K's, 3.56 ERA, 1.15 WHIP
Zero injuries
Why would Carl drop? He was injured. Hamstrings and wrist. Thats not very fair.
Bj is debatable. He upped his steals but his power went down because of a torn labrum in his shoulder. He should return to 20 HR being healthy. He will miss the first week of the season.
Pena is also borderline. His power is indisputable. His defense is amazing. He also takes a lot of walks. His average isn't great and he k's a lot. He should be rated higher than guys like Dunn though because of his defense.