Try this!
Pitching: CPU Settings
AI Pitch Success: 70
AI Pitch Selection Tendency: 80
AI Strike Zone Tendency: 15
AI Pitch Zone Tendency: 20
AI Pitcher Composure Influence: 75
Batting: User Settings
This is what I'm about to test right now I Had
AI Strike Zone Tendency: 25 but I never struck out and it was Zambrano pitching and keep in mind I had this for Batting!
Batting: User Settings
Batting Success: 50
Batter Contact: 0
Batter Power: 50
Pitcher Handedness Influence: 100
Inside Edge Batter Zone Influence: 100
Batting Pitch Influence: 75
Batter’s Eye Influence: 0
Hit Direction Influence: 50
Batter’s Eye Influence: 25
Zone Hitting Influence: 50
Bunt Contact: 0
Bunt Success: 0