Disabled list broken?

[Azamien]

OK, is this a major bug/oversight, or am I missing something?

I had two guys get injured in one day. One minor leaguer and one major leaguer. I moved them both to the disabled list, with the minor league player going to the 15 day DL and the major league player going to the 60 day DL (with a broken arm after getting hit in the head, but that's another post for another day).

But by all appearances and execution, it seems that both players are still counting against their team's roster limit, and the man on the 60 day DL is still counting against the 40 man roster.

I tried to sign a free agent to fill the role on my MLB team, but the game says my roster is full even though I only have 24 active players (the roster breakdown still says 25, even though one is on the DL). Then I tried to bring up my next best option, but it says my 40 man roster is full, and the injured player can't be removed since he's injured, even though someone on the 60 day DL isn't supposed to count against the 40 man roster.

So please tell me I'm missing something, because as it is right now franchise is nearly unplayable if you have anyone get injured.

[JahCreations]

Re: Disabled list broken?

same here I have 3 guys on the 60 day dl and 2 on the 15 and my minor league teams are taking a beating because of it. I swear last year you could sign another player if you had someone on the 60 day dl.. I would also like to know how to fix this..

[EnigmaNemesis]

Re: Disabled list broken?

The 15 day DL will still count against the roster limit ... but the 60 day should not. Lets hope they know about this, and a fix is in notion ... do you guys have the recent 1.01 patch by chance?

[Azamien]

Re: Disabled list broken?

The 15 day DL will still count against the roster limit ... but the 60 day should not. If there is a way to get this repeatable we can see if it wasn't a fluke glitch or not.

The 15 day doesn't count against the 25 man roster, or else the entire reason for having a disabled list is null.

The problem is that the 15 day in The Show counting against the 25 man, and the 60 day is counting against both the 25 man and the 40 man. At the moment, at least in my franchise, that makes both lists completely worthless.

[Knight165]

Re: Disabled list broken?

OK, is this a major bug/oversight, or am I missing something?

I had two guys get injured in one day. One minor leaguer and one major leaguer. I moved them both to the disabled list, with the minor league player going to the 15 day DL and the major league player going to the 60 day DL (with a broken arm after getting hit in the head, but that's another post for another day).

But by all appearances and execution, it seems that both players are still counting against their team's roster limit, and the man on the 60 day DL is still counting against the 40 man roster.

I tried to sign a free agent to fill the role on my MLB team, but the game says my roster is full even though I only have 24 active players (the roster breakdown still says 25, even though one is on the DL). Then I tried to bring up my next best option, but it says my 40 man roster is full, and the injured player can't be removed since he's injured, even though someone on the 60 day DL isn't supposed to count against the 40 man roster.

So please tell me I'm missing something, because as it is right now franchise is nearly unplayable if you have anyone get injured.

You are right it seems...
I just tried it.
I'm sending this one directly to SCEA....

M.K.
Knight165

[Azamien]

Re: Disabled list broken?

You are right it seems...
I just tried it.
I'm sending this one directly to SCEA....

M.K.
Knight165

Ugh.

Thanks Knight.

I guess I'll stick to RTTS until next patch, because there's no real way to continue my franchise as it stands. Oh well. At least RTTS is fun.

[Knight165]

Re: Disabled list broken?

same here I have 3 guys on the 60 day dl and 2 on the 15 and my minor league teams are taking a beating because of it. I swear last year you could sign another player if you had someone on the 60 day dl.. I would also like to know how to fix this..

You could...for sure.

M.K.
Knight165

[JahCreations]

Re: Disabled list broken?

seriously how could this be missed in testing.. its a huge factor of Franchise mode.

[EnigmaNemesis]

Re: Disabled list broken?

The 15 day doesn't count against the 25 man roster, or else the entire reason for having a disabled list is null.

The problem is that the 15 day in The Show counting against the 25 man, and the 60 day is counting against both the 25 man and the 40 man. At the moment, at least in my franchise, that makes both lists completely worthless.

I edited it, what I am saying is 15 day still counts against the 40 man, but the 60 should not count against either.

[Scottdau]

Re: Disabled list broken?

seriously how could this be missed in testing.. its a huge factor of Franchise mode.

I will make one of those educational guesses. It is a new feature.

[Azamien]

Re: Disabled list broken?

seriously how could this be missed in testing.. its a huge factor of Franchise mode.

I'm wondering if it was a bug introduced in the patch that went out yesterday. I find it hard to believe that I'd be the first person to notice this (and then post about it) if it had been that way the previous week.

[EnigmaNemesis]

Re: Disabled list broken?

I'm wondering if it was a bug introduced in the patch that went out yesterday. I find it hard to believe that I'd be the first person to notice this (and then post about it) if it had been that way the previous week.

One should delete the patch and try and replicate this and see if it does the same thing.

[Knight165]

Re: Disabled list broken?

I sent this along to Russ....

I'm going to delete my install and see if it was introduced in the patch.

M.K.
Knight165

[bcruise]

Re: Disabled list broken?

It might not be much of a fix, but maybe try putting the lineup management stuff on CPU and sim a day or so to see what happens, if the auto-fix CPU control does something about it. Just make sure you save a separate file beforehand because it'll probably re-arrange your batting order too...

[NEWYORICAN]

Re: Disabled list broken?

I will make one of those educational guesses. It is a new feature.

Do you mean having the disabled list is a new feature?....hummm