[Pared]

Quote: Originally Posted by Pappy Knuckles

2. Anyone who says 2K football is stiff just hasn't played it enough. You can't run around crazily tapping the button because you have to slow down to set stuff up. How you move the stick is critical. When I play APF it feels like football to me. Ricky Waters doesn't run like Emmitt, and Emmitt doesn't run like Gale Sayers. You can definitely feel the difference. The players in APF have a "weight" that I'd like to see in Madden.

You can really see this when people say they prefer the feeling of "control" over Madden.

You shouldn't have control 100% of the time with a controller if the physics and motion system is up to snuff.

I'm sure that last comment will be dissected but thumbs up to those who actually realize the difference.