C'mon man....seriously! That pic with the loose sleeves and pulled up socks completely makes Manning look like Manning. I guess it is in the eye of the beholder because I noticed the differences right away and I have to say it makes a very big difference.
Lets put it this way for all of you who play lets say NBA 2k9 or Live...If Kobe was running around with shorts that were tight and did not move when he ran would that make a difference to you? Or if AI didn't have his arm sleeve, would that make a difference to you? If you are playing a sports simulation that is trying to re-create realism then getting even things like sleeves correct is important to most of us IMO.