Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

[Derrville]

Madden top 10 rated quarterbacks in order:

1. P Manning: 99

2. Brady: 98

3. Brees: 97

4. Warner: 94

5. Roethlisberger: 93

6. Mcnabb: 91

7. Romo: 88

Rivers: 88

9. Cutler: 87

E. Manning: 87

[Exonerated]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

wow Brady 98. Did not see that coming at all. And Rivers was the best rated QB last season, better than Mcnabb Imo.

But I don't agree with Brady 98. More like 96 with Brees the second best.

[Derrville]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

hmmm

[Scott]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

No complaints with these from me...

[KANE699]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Not usually one to complain about ratings but yea I would like to see Brady go down a few points after missing all season to a 96 or 95.

[Krodis]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

I'd say McNabb and Eli are a little high and Rivers is low if anything, to be honest. Romo and Cutler might be high too but it's hard to say.

[fourthreemafia]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Cutler is too high.

[Scott]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Cutler is too high.

Why? He threw for 4500 yards, 62%, and an 86 QB Rating....Rivers could get a jump though...

[Heelblue702]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

wow Brady 98. Did not see that coming at all. And Rivers was the best rated QB last season, better than Mcnabb Imo.

But I don't agree with Brady 98. More like 96 with Brees the second best.

I agree with you on that one. Not only McNabb but Tony Romo too. I don't think they should be rated the same. Rivers is a better QB IMO.

[Krodis]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Why? He threw for 4500 yards, 62%, and an 86 QB Rating....Rivers could get a jump though...

62% and an 86 QB Rating are average, not spectacular. He had some problem with poor decision making.

[joejccva71]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

I think Brady's OVR should be around 95 now. When a QB misses an entire season you have no idea how he's going to be the next year.

I pretty much agree with everything else except I think Rivers should be 91.

[fourthreemafia]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Why? He threw for 4500 yards, 62%, and an 86 QB Rating....Rivers could get a jump though...

People overrate numbers.

I was a big Cutler fan until this year.

He is terribly un-clutch. Picked apart crap teams.

Not saying he cant or wont be better, but at this point, he should be rating that high. 84 or 85 IMO.

[the-son-of-85]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

thats bulls### brady never played all season and hes 98 and carson palmer played 2 games and hes not in the top ten what are these people doing

[the-son-of-85]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

carson palmer is not in the top 10 ,, but brady is 98 overall and never played last season but they know football.........

[gr18]

Re: Official Madden NFL 10 Top 10 Ouarterback Ratings

Palmer,Hasselbeck and Bulger will take a much bigger hit than Brady because even though they may have played injured to some degree,they played like crap.

Brady was great the last time he played.If it were an injury that he could've come back from and then put up a 70 quarterback rating,he would be several points lower.