Madden NFL 10 Full Rookie Ratings File

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JeriousNorwood
    Pro
    • Apr 2009
    • 570

    #31
    Re: All Rookie Ratings

    I asked you to find me a link where it said he is stronger than Beanie Wells. You clearly failed.

    Look, I'm not defending him in any way because I've never watched the guy you are talking about play in person. However, when you guys say that bench reps = strength, it's really stupid and shows how unaware you guys are of what goes into ratings.

    Comment

    • adub88
      Pro
      • May 2003
      • 964

      #32
      Re: All Rookie Ratings

      Originally posted by JeriousNorwood
      I asked you to find me a link where it said he is stronger than Beanie Wells. You clearly failed.

      Look, I'm not defending him in any way because I've never watched the guy you are talking about play in person. However, when you guys say that bench reps = strength, it's really stupid and shows how unaware you guys are of what goes into ratings.
      I don't know about anyone else, but what I posted had to do with his on field and in the gym strength.
      NFL:Colts
      NBA:KINGS

      Comment

      • kehlis
        Moderator
        • Jul 2008
        • 27738

        #33
        Re: All Rookie Ratings

        Originally posted by JeriousNorwood
        I asked you to find me a link where it said he is stronger than Beanie Wells. You clearly failed.
        But this was a stupid request. Why would ANYONE compare the two in a scouting report.

        Comment

        • Anti Honor
          Rookie
          • Feb 2007
          • 474

          #34
          Re: All Rookie Ratings

          Originally posted by adub88
          part of Taylor's scouting report from NFL.COM

          http://www.nfl.com/draft/2009/profil...aylor?id=79655
          Overview

          A three-year starter at nose guard, Taylor's squat, thick frame resembles a fire hydrant, but he attacks blockers like a runaway fire truck.

          Taylor delivered one of the best performances in the weight room at the 2009 NFL Combine, recording 37 repetitions bench-pressing 225 pounds. Strength has always been his biggest asset.

          He set Michigan prep records with a 500-pound bench press, 680-pound squat and a
          670-pound dead lift.


          The common thing I keep hearing about him, is that he's super strong in the gym and on the field, so that 78 got to change.
          Thanks a ton.

          I'm not saying Taylor's overall should rise, because he's not the most talented guy in the world, nor is he the brightest guy, never has been. But one thing people haven't questioned, is his strength. His durability is an issue, his heart/desire or lack of has been questioned (highschool), but never his strength.

          Call me nitpicky, but I really question how much research was done with certain rookie ratings. Especially some of the lower guys.
          Last edited by Anti Honor; 04-26-2009, 09:09 PM.

          Comment

          • ImReady77
            Rookie
            • Jun 2003
            • 370

            #35
            Re: All Rookie Ratings

            Originally posted by JeriousNorwood
            I asked you to find me a link where it said he is stronger than Beanie Wells. You clearly failed.

            Look, I'm not defending him in any way because I've never watched the guy you are talking about play in person. However, when you guys say that bench reps = strength, it's really stupid and shows how unaware you guys are of what goes into ratings.
            WTF!!! Did beanie wells break state records in lifting? Did beanie wells place 8th in powerlifting for ostate? No he didn't so stop trying to be mr. smartass. I don't care what u think about the bench press but when a man does almost 40reps in the bench they are strong as hell.

            Comment

            • Primerica
              Rookie
              • Nov 2007
              • 470

              #36
              Re: All Rookie Ratings

              Really, Chris Owens a 58 while Coye Frances a 74. Chris Owens is a potential lockdown corner who wasn't even challege becuase of his talent and he has a lower rating then Coye. LOL, let's come back to this rating comparision in two years.

              Comment

              • JeriousNorwood
                Pro
                • Apr 2009
                • 570

                #37
                Re: All Rookie Ratings

                Originally posted by Anti Honor
                Oh really?

                Link me to any scout that says Chris ''Beanie'' Wells is stronger than Terrance Taylor.
                To one of the above posters, I was just throwing this guys argument in his face. No one compares the two, so why in the hell would he ask?

                Again, I'm not saying he's not strong, I'm saying bench press is not everything that matters, but so many of you live or die by it. The game of football is not based solely on combine numbers, nor should that be the sole thing that determines the ratings in Madden.

                Comment

                • Anti Honor
                  Rookie
                  • Feb 2007
                  • 474

                  #38
                  Re: All Rookie Ratings

                  My argument is that Terrance Taylor is stronger than 78.

                  Even Ricky-Jean Francois got an 81 strength rating.

                  There isn't a scout, head coach or website that would question Terrance Taylor's strength, and this dates back to highschool, so I'd like to know what ''scout'' Donny Moore got this info from, since I was told that's probably how Donny decided on the rating.

                  I already sent the info needed via PM to Donny, so perhaps now, he'll actually do a little research on Taylor, and boost his strength up a notch or 10.

                  Comment

                  • Hooe
                    Hall Of Fame
                    • Aug 2002
                    • 21555

                    #39
                    Re: All Rookie Ratings

                    Okay, I don't normally bemoan Madden player ratings, but I'm absolutely baffled that Ravens rookie RB Cedric Peerman has a carrying rating of 60. As a student at UVa, I've watched all four of his playing years here and I've only seen him fumble the ball twice ever as a Cavalier.

                    Also, despite his awesome workout numbers, Peerman probably doesn't deserve a speed rating of 94, and probably should be a far more balanced back vs. being an exclusively a shifty, speedy back. He was never a burner and was more of the workhorse type (not to be confused with being a power runner, though; he wasn't that either). His most exceptional qualities, in my opinion, were probably his passion, work ethic, never-say-die attitude, patience, and ability to recognize a hole and hit it immediately; that said I have no idea how to translate those qualities to the Madden ratings scale.

                    Finally, he also plausibly deserves a higher kick return rating; during his first two years he was the primary kick returner for the Cavaliers and averaged just under 27 yards a return, before being moved off special teams to assume the primary running back job.
                    Last edited by Hooe; 04-26-2009, 10:34 PM.

                    Comment

                    • Anti Honor
                      Rookie
                      • Feb 2007
                      • 474

                      #40
                      Re: All Rookie Ratings

                      Originally posted by Krioniq
                      Okay, I don't normally bemoan Madden player ratings, but I'm absolutely baffled that Ravens rookie RB Cedric Peerman has a carrying rating of 60. I watched all four of his playing years here at Virginia and I've only seen him fumble the ball twice ever as a Cavalier.
                      Probably that same nasty little ''scout'' that told Donny Terrance Taylor is one of the weakest DTs in football.

                      Comment

                      • Potatoes002
                        MVP
                        • Jul 2008
                        • 2143

                        #41
                        Re: All Rookie Ratings

                        Can someone tell me what Brandon Gibson ratings are? Hes the WR for the Eagles 6th round pick.

                        Comment

                        • Scott
                          Your Go-to TV Expert
                          • Jul 2002
                          • 20032

                          #42
                          Re: All Rookie Ratings

                          Originally posted by Potatoes002
                          Can someone tell me what Brandon Gibson ratings are? Hes the WR for the Eagles 6th round pick.
                          65 OVR - 87 SPD - 86 ACC - 85 AGI - 75 CTH - 86 JMP - 82 ELUS - 80 SPIN - 83 JUKE
                          PSN-Shugarooo
                          Steam-ScottM.816
                          Twitch.tv/Shugarooo
                          Want to follow my Franchises? Join my discord: https://discord.gg/nHbNCWmmGs

                          Comment

                          • peteykirch
                            Banned
                            • Apr 2006
                            • 3944

                            #43
                            Re: All Rookie Ratings

                            Does EA seriously even look at combine/pro day/college games when it comes to their ratings?

                            Tiquan Underwood 4.34 and a 4.40 40 yard dash = 89 Speed.
                            Beanie Wells 4.56 40 yard dash = 89 Speed.

                            Also WTF at not having Teel's ratings? You have the ratings for QBs who weren't drafted, but a 5th rounder = No Ratings? I don't even want to see his rating now, just on the basis if the undrafted QBs are on this spreadsheet and they are at 51, Teel is a 33.

                            Comment

                            • kcarr
                              MVP
                              • Sep 2008
                              • 2787

                              #44
                              Re: All Rookie Ratings

                              Originally posted by Potatoes002
                              Can someone tell me what Brandon Gibson ratings are? Hes the WR for the Eagles 6th round pick.
                              65 overall, 87 speed, 60 strength, 85 agility, 44 awareness, 75 catch, 55 carry, 86 jump, 40 return, 88 injury, 85 stamina, 75 toughness, 45 trucking, 82 elusiveness, 74 ball carrier vision, 40 stiff arm, 80 spin, 83 juke, 33 impact blocking, 33 RBS, 30 RBF, 66 spectacular catch, 78 in traffic, 74 route running, 57 release

                              Comment

                              • Potatoes002
                                MVP
                                • Jul 2008
                                • 2143

                                #45
                                Re: All Rookie Ratings

                                Originally posted by Scott
                                65 OVR - 87 SPD - 86 ACC - 85 AGI - 75 CTH - 86 JMP - 82 ELUS - 80 SPIN - 83 JUKE
                                Thanks! Sounds about good, i might only bump hes catch to like 79 and spd, acc, and agi about 2 points higher because he was injured and missed pro day, combine, and senior bowl so it hurt his draft stock.

                                Comment

                                Working...