Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post

masterkembo · 04-27-2009, 03:49 PM

Ratings look good overall - there's a few surprises / dissapointments but considering so much can change, rookie ratings must be a thankless job. If it was easy, no one would pay as much as they do to NFL Scouts.

I was surprised to see that Duke Robinson was rated so high (80 ovr). I really don't think the number 1 rated interior offensive lineman should be a guy that was drafted in the 5th round.

In addition, I'm dissapointed in Wood's rating for the Bill's - would be happy if he got bumped up to a 73/74 I think. All off season, people have been comparing Mack, Wood and Unger and while Mack is likely the best of the 3 hands down, Wood should be at least at the same level as Unger I think (perhaps, this is just my biasness speaking though).

Actually, thought Nelson was a little low too, considering he was the #2 TE on a lot of peoples boards behind Pettigrew and many think it was the steal of the draft. Oh well though...(can you tell who I am a fan of..haha)

04-27-2009, 03:49 PM	#84
masterkembo Pro OVR: 9 Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: Waterloo, Ontario	Re: Madden NFL 10 Full Rookie Ratings File Ratings look good overall - there's a few surprises / dissapointments but considering so much can change, rookie ratings must be a thankless job. If it was easy, no one would pay as much as they do to NFL Scouts. I was surprised to see that Duke Robinson was rated so high (80 ovr). I really don't think the number 1 rated interior offensive lineman should be a guy that was drafted in the 5th round. In addition, I'm dissapointed in Wood's rating for the Bill's - would be happy if he got bumped up to a 73/74 I think. All off season, people have been comparing Mack, Wood and Unger and while Mack is likely the best of the 3 hands down, Wood should be at least at the same level as Unger I think (perhaps, this is just my biasness speaking though). Actually, thought Nelson was a little low too, considering he was the #2 TE on a lot of peoples boards behind Pettigrew and many think it was the steal of the draft. Oh well though...(can you tell who I am a fan of..haha)